I believe that the first poster is sufficiently accurate that it COULD have happened just that way. And, I believe that the 2nd poster knows his deer capture methods. I got the same email some time ago.. may have even been last year.
Ive taught my sons to shoot deer in the head. Makes for a simple track down. Their last 15 or so deer have all been shot that way. When my youngest son was about 15 and had been hunting since age 8 or so, he had a memorable experience.
He was in a blind, a buck came into sight and he pulled down on the head and fired. The buck dropped in his tracks and my son went over to him. He got there and kicked the deer, which was flat on the ground and kinda stiff with one leg kicking. Having been trained to be frugal with his shots and humane to his prey, he laid down his rifle, pulled out his knife, approached from the rear, grabbed a horn to pull the neck back to cut its throat and let it bleed out.
The buck began struggling to get up and my son observed that the other antler was freshly busted. His shot had hit the antler and rattled the deers brains quite completely

Well, the rifle was too far away to reach and he had a handful of antler attached to a deer that was rapidly regaining his sense of balance. What ensued must have been a sight to behold. He did succeed in cutting the deers throat, but not before the deer pulled him off balance on to the ground. Thus, the throat was cut with the deer standing over him alternatively trying to get away, pawing and trying to ram him. Cutting the throat in this position guarantees that copious amounts of blood will be spilled from the cuttee onto the cutter.
When I drove up to pick him up, all I saw was my completely bloody boy standing beside a dead deer. Of course, I knew from his vertical position that the blood could not be his, but I had to hear the story to understand where it had come from... It just never occured to me that a person could get so bloody while hunting

He made a dramatic entrance back at the house... all the women folk screamed and exclaimed while he and I just grinned