Help me decide - X595 vs. X728

[tkenney65]

OK…hopefully my last “I need help” posting. Down to the wire with my tractor purchase, now I could use some advice from the experts on which way to lean.

2005 X595 (54” mower/4WD diesel engine w/29 hours) $10,191

2006 X728 (54” mower/4WD gas engine w/0 hours) $10,810

I will be using it to mow primarily, with some light landscaping duties around the yard. In the future I intend to add the 47” 2-stage snowthrower.

Thanks in advance!!!

 

[beenthere]

What are you giving up to go with the X728?

 

[awlchu]

My vote is for the Diesel. How much of the warranty is left over?

 

[tkenney65]

Not giving up anything to get this. It is my first tractor purchase.

The warranty on the 2005 X595 is good until May 2007

 

[cast_and_blast]

Diesel is the way to go.

 

[johndeere_2210]

Personally, I think you should purchase a 2305 with 54" deck, and bet it nearly the same money, but that wasn't your question, just my opinion.

As for the two, 595 and don't look back.

 

[JDGREEN4ME]

I would also go with the diesel. Seen too much on here about how big a fuel hog the gas model is.

 

[JDFANATIC]

tkenney, What's the scoop? Thought you were looking at 2210's and 2305's? For the minor differences in price, I wouldn't be compromising what you ultimately would get out of the tractor. In other words, don't save a few $'s only to not be happy with what you ended up with. /forums/images/graemlins/confused.gif

 

[tkenney65]

JDFANATIC,

You are right! I am a bit all over the board right now. I love the 2305 but have convinced myself that it is too much machine for my needs. I like the option of having a loader but am unsure if spending the extra $$$ is worth it or not. Can you tell I am confused? I am also paranoid about not being able to collect the grass clippings with a collection system! The price differenc right now between my 2305 quote and the X595 quote is about $4K...pretty big. The X595 is not cheap either but the 2305 puts me right at the limit of what I want to spend.


Tim

 

[rockyridgefarm]

two thoughts.
It is very common for folks to think that a machine is too big up front, only to 'grow into' the size. They seem to shrink as you use them!

also, is collection that bad on the sCUTs? and why not mulch?

 

[johncny]

Wow, something doesn't seem right. My quote for a 2305 was about $1K LESS than comparably equipped x700. Except the 2305 included the 3pt, rear pto and ROPS too! Made it a no-brainer. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

 

[wxboy]

I come up with a list price of $12,270 for a 2305 with 54C MMM. That's only 2 grand more than the X595 and you should be able to get the dealer down from list. I paid $11,200 for the same setup plus $2,500 for the fel.

I was also considering an X-series and because the prices were so close and the 2305 could do so much more that's the direction I went and I'm very happy with it. I only have an acre of land and yes it's overkill but it mows great and it's capable of so much down the road.

I would either go with the X595 because of the diesel or go with the 2305. Resale was also a factor in my decision in case I am forced to sell in the near future.

 

[beenthere]

I looked up the specs on the X728, and answered my own question. That is:
you are giving up the diesel if you go to the X728. Kinda gathered that when reading the others' responses.

I'd go with the X595 if making a choice between the two. /forums/images/graemlins/tongue.gif

 

[tkenney65]

wxboy,

Cheapest price I can find here in Southern NH is $14,050 for the 2305 w/54"MMM, 200CX Loader and Ballast. Mind if I ask where you bought yours?

Tim

 

[Shawk]

Not answering your question on "vs."... however, unless you have specific reasons... absolutely go with the 2210 or 2305. More machine for the money. Also opens more options for you down the road.... like a FEL or ??? /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

 

[JDFANATIC]

From what I've heard, the NH dealers don't discount very much. The MSRP on that package is $15183. So it is discounted some, but probably $900 higher than other states.

 

[tkenney65]

That's what I figured. Maybe I can find a better deal in a neighboring state and pick it up myself.

 

[Gorbie]

Go new and get the new warrenty. If you like smelling diesel fumes all day as you use it, get the diesel! Either way... you are looking at getting a Deere and that's okay! You will get years of use out of either purchase. Enjoy!
Cheers, MIKE

 

[JDFANATIC]

Actually, the only time you really smell anything diesel, is when filling the tractor, or if you were to use it in a closed area. Today's diesels are leaps and bounds more efficient then yesterday's. My wife hates getting stuck behind a smelly old bus, but has never complained about any of my diesel tractors.

 

[cast_and_blast]

I already answered the question (see previous post), but if you're open to other machines then I would jump all over a 2305 and not look back.

Yep, it's a bit more. But, they have 3 year 0% financing (if that is a factor) right now. Yep, it will do a WHOLE BUNCH more. 3 point, rear PTO, diesel, full warranty, loader, ROPS.

I'm not an owner of a 2305, yet. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Mine will have the 200CX loader, a 62C MMM. I would really reconsider the 54" vs. 62" deck, the turning radius on the 2305 is really good - if you have trees or landscaping to maneuver around it may be helpful.

I don't understand the comment about material collection? My understanding is that they are releasing a powerflow system that will house the bag system on the 3 point. I think this will be similar to what you find on a X series. My preference would be to have it run off of the rear PTO (it's there, why wouldn't you want to USE it?). Don't limit yourself to just JD when thinking material collection. I know trac vac makes a PTO powered system too.

As far as over kill goes, I have 1.5 acres. I have landscaping to do, I have yard to mow twice per week, my property is tree lined and they drop lots of leaves. Could I get away with something smaller? Yes. Would I regret it at some point down the road? Absolutely.

Just like tools, I'm too cheap to buy the wrong stuff. Buy the right thing the first time - you'll be better off in the long run.

In term of wx's prices - you're only $300 away from his price. IMHO it's worth that to buy local.

Good Luck!

Scott