I wasn’t clear. The cabinets where not built by the home owner. In my opinion, they are something you would expect from a Big Box type of store. I do not think a cabinet shop made them. They are not really great cabinets. You might even say that they are kind of cheap cabinets. There isn’t anything wrong with them, but there isn’t anything great about them. She is in her 70s and she just wants it all done so her kids can inherit a finished home.
You are sure making this hard for us Eddie but maybe everyone gets on the same page soon. The doors might not be homeowner built but there's less than 1 in 1k chance they are from big box. As for them being nothing special,beauty is in the eyes of beholder. In my estimation those doors are just as desirable as 50% of doors installed in new homes this week. The picture doesn't change my mind on best way of duplicating doors using 2 piece trim to hold panel.I took another picture of the door to show that each stile and rail are one piece.
View attachment 805683
They are definitely one-piece. And the panel groove is rounded, not square.I took another picture of the door to show that each stile and rail are one piece.
View attachment 805683
Nice joint. Did the wife get rid of her husband's molding cutters and router bits after he passed? If she still has them, that might be your best chance of actually finding the cutter / bit he used.
Oh you can still get custom cutters made if you really want to. Expensive, naturally. I doubt this situation is significant enough to warrant it. Based on a couple postings, there are bits that should come down to "close enough" for this. It isn't a matching restoration at Buckingham Palace or something. It just needs to be close enough to be passable. And even thought the original now appears to be one piece, doesn't mean you can't make the replacements as a tacked-on molding. With glue and a 23 ga pin nailer, nobody would know. Ya just need to decide how deep you want to go down this rabbit hole.Unfortunate.
There used to be places that would custom make a cutter to fit a profile if you have anyone near you who could do it.