how well built are Workmaster 55

[SETexan]

I am thinking of upgrading my tractor and have narrowed the search to few tractors. On the short list is the work master. How well built are these tractors? This will be by 3rd tractor, the first was 1953 Ford NAA Golden Jubilee, and the second and current is a 2005 New Holland TC48DA. I want MFWD and a FEL which is why i am thinking about trading. I wish NH still made my TC48!!! i would just get another one with MFWD, FEL and be done but, they don't.

Anybody that has a WM55 feel free to jump in and let me know how well it has performed and how you use it.

Pricing i have gotten is from one reputable dealer that i currently use to get filters and such my current tractor.

Used 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD and less than 200hrs $21.9k
New 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD $26.4k
New 2011 Workmaster 65 with FEL , MFWD $25.5k

Is the pricing about right???

 

[SETexan]

I have tested three workmaster tractors and all three had a horrible whine in transmission. Is this normal?

 

[eagle107]

I am thinking of upgrading my tractor and have narrowed the search to few tractors. On the short list is the work master. How well built are these tractors? This will be by 3rd tractor, the first was 1953 Ford NAA Golden Jubilee, and the second and current is a 2005 New Holland TC48DA. I want MFWD and a FEL which is why i am thinking about trading. I wish NH still made my TC48!!! i would just get another one with MFWD, FEL and be done but, they don't.

Anybody that has a WM55 feel free to jump in and let me know how well it has performed and how you use it.


Pricing i have gotten is from one reputable dealer that i currently use to get filters and such my current tractor.

Used 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD and less than 200hrs $21.9k
New 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD $26.4k
New 2011 Workmaster 65 with FEL , MFWD $25.5k

Is the pricing about right???

Shibaura made one heck of a utility tractor for New Holland with the TC48DA and TC55DA. They are great tractors! The same type of tractor as your TC48DA would be a Boomer 4055 or 4060; just with more HP. New Holland stopped selling the Boomer 4055 and 4060 around 2010, however, you can still find some on tractorhouse.com or see if your dealer can get you one. I am not a fan of the Workmasters. You might want to look at the new PowerStar 4.75 tractor. It is suppose to be a great tractor if it is not too big for you. You can always look at the John Deere 5000 series (the 5Ms are very nice), Mahindra 5035 or 5530 4WD Shuttle, a Kubota M5140 or the Massey Ferguson 2600 Series Utility tractor.

 

[SETexan]

The three i am looking at are the Kubota M5140, JD 5055e and the workmaster. The kubota is the highest priced with the workmaster priced the lowest by a large margin.

The kubota has the most features but, also has a EGR which i don't want.

If the workmaster transmission didn't whine it would be in the lead but, right now the JD is leading.

I started three threads one in general, one in the john deere section and this one all asking about the same thing. I guess nobody has anything to say about the workmasters which should probably tell me something.

The most disappointing part of all of this is the new holland dealer is by far superior to the other two dealers in my area.

 

[EHR]

Is the Workmaster a LS tractor?

 

[eagle107]

No. The LS tractors are the newer Boomer 20 - 50 compact tractor line for New Holland. The Workmasters are the newer economy line of utility tractors for New Holland.

 

[MrWhippy]

With 200 hours on my WM55, I am completely happy with the tractor. Great hydraulics, great FEL, 4WD. Yes, there's some whine in the transmission, but I see no evidence of damage. More likely straight cut gears in the box (which many feel are stronger teeth than spiral cut teeth).

It is a lot of tractor for the money.

 

[farmall 55a case]

I have the same thing as the wm55 just the red version the farmall 55 A and i love it! Dose every thing i ask of it no complaints! Get it you wont regret it!

 

[Bigfoot62]

The three i am looking at are the Kubota M5140, JD 5055e and the workmaster. The kubota is the highest priced with the workmaster priced the lowest by a large margin. . . .

Just realize that the Workmaster is an economy tractor. (so is the JD 5055e) It does not have the same features, driveline, etc., as the T4020 or T4030. For instance, the WM has a gear reduction final drive and smaller lift arms. It does not have the same 3ph capacity as the T series. The transmission is different, the clutch is different, the T series has better hydraulics, the T4020 weighs over a ton more than the WM, etc, etc, etc.
If you really want a NH, I would suggest that you look hard at the T series.
Here's the NH specs for both tractors. Look for yourself. Then compare them side-by-side at the dealer.
Agricultural-Tractors New Holland Workmaster - Models, technical data and characteristics
Agricultural-Tractors New Holland T4000 - Models, technical data and characteristics
BTW, I have a TN70A. (basically, same tractor as the T4030) And, it's a great machine. Love it. I put about 200 hours per year on it. I wouldn't even consider a WM, myself.

 

[farmall 55a case]

Its over half the price for a tractor that is very capable!

 

[SETexan]

the dealer is looking for a 4020 but, i'm not sure how much more they are compared to the WM. I'm guessing maybe 9000-10000 more, which is way more than i want to spend. with that being said, i do not want to settle for less tractor soley based on price.

 

[MrWhippy]

Just realize that the Workmaster is an economy tractor. (so is the JD 5055e) It does not have the same features, driveline, etc., as the T4020 or T4030. For instance, the WM has a gear reduction final drive and smaller lift arms. It does not have the same 3ph capacity as the T series. The transmission is different, the clutch is different, the T series has better hydraulics, the T4020 weighs over a ton more than the WM, etc, etc, etc.
If you really want a NH, I would suggest that you look hard at the T series.
Here's the NH specs for both tractors. Look for yourself. Then compare them side-by-side at the dealer.
Agricultural-Tractors New Holland Workmaster - Models, technical data and characteristics
Agricultural-Tractors New Holland T4000 - Models, technical data and characteristics
BTW, I have a TN70A. (basically, same tractor as the T4030) And, it's a great machine. Love it. I put about 200 hours per year on it. I wouldn't even consider a WM, myself.

Looking at those spec pages, it seems to me the only things you "give up" on the WM are, factory option cab, and transmission options. The other thing I really liked about the WM series was the lack of electronics in critical systems. For me, that means 10 years down the line, I don't have to worry about dodgy grounds causing reliability issues.

Again, in my circumstance (35 acre horse farm), if the tractor can do the work I need it to do, simplicity and ease of repair trumps comfort and convenience every day. If I spent 6-8 hours a day, multiple days per week, week after week, in the seat, comfort and convenience would have a higher importance.

 

[SDT]

I am thinking of upgrading my tractor and have narrowed the search to few tractors. On the short list is the work master. How well built are these tractors? This will be by 3rd tractor, the first was 1953 Ford NAA Golden Jubilee, and the second and current is a 2005 New Holland TC48DA. I want MFWD and a FEL which is why i am thinking about trading. I wish NH still made my TC48!!! i would just get another one with MFWD, FEL and be done but, they don't.

Anybody that has a WM55 feel free to jump in and let me know how well it has performed and how you use it.

Pricing i have gotten is from one reputable dealer that i currently use to get filters and such my current tractor.

Used 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD and less than 200hrs $21.9k
New 2012 Workmaster 55 with FEL, MFWD $26.4k
New 2011 Workmaster 65 with FEL , MFWD $25.5k

Is the pricing about right???

One point that has not been mentioned previously in this thread is the Workmaster series does not have a fully synchronized main transmission. Rather, the main transmission is synchronized in third and fourth only. This was enough to remove it from my consideration list when shopping for a no frills mowing tractor.

SDT

 

[MrWhippy]

One point that has not been mentioned previously in this thread is the Workmaster series does not have a fully synchronized main transmission. Rather, the main transmission is synchronized in third and fourth only. This was enough to remove it from my consideration list when shopping for a no frills mowing tractor.

This is true. If you spend a lot of time shifting gears (not just forward/reverse, which is a shuttle shift), the transmission would be offputting.

 

[Bigfoot62]

Never said that an economy tractor wasn't "capable." Just said that it ain't the same. I don't know about you but I work my tractors. In addition to other tasks, I cut, rake, and bale about 90 acres of hay meadows, three to four times per year. For instance, the T4020 will handle a 1000 roll of hay on the FEL. I'd be willing to bet the WM would have to have rear ballast to pick it up, and even then, it's not going to be as stable as the T series that weighs 2300# more. When mowing, having twice as many gears to choose from on the T series comes in very handy. Etc, etc, etc. That's all I'm saying. They are not in the same category.

 

[Bigfoot62]

Looking at those spec pages, it seems to me the only things you "give up" on the WM are, factory option cab, and transmission options. . .

With all due respect sir, you're WAY off.
I see in your signature that you have a 5600. The WM 65 is supposed to be roughly the same hp as your old Ford. If you can find a dealer that has one, just go drive it around the lot, shift the gears, and take a long hard look at the lift arms, axle housings, etc. It ain't the same tractor. I'll bet that if you're honest, you wouldn't trade your 5600 for it even.

 

[MrWhippy]

Agree that I wish there was a lower low gear. Here's a picture of the loader with bolt on forks carrying 13 pressure treated 8 foot long 6-7 inch round posts. 70-80 lbs a piece. We have carried many more on the forks. BTW the rears are weighted.

We've pulled a Woods 312 (12 foot batwing) mower with it as well.

As for not the same, probably true. But I'll say again, I would rather have a simple tractor I can fix myself and sacrifice some convenience features. If I could buy a brand new Ford 5600 (4wd version of my old one) I would in a heartbeat. Simple to fix, stone reliable.

 

[MrWhippy]

With all due respect sir, you're WAY off.
I see in your signature that you have a 5600. The WM 65 is supposed to be roughly the same hp as your old Ford. If you can find a dealer that has one, just go drive it around the lot, shift the gears, and take a long hard look at the lift arms, axle housings, etc. It ain't the same tractor. I'll bet that if you're honest, you wouldn't trade your 5600 for it even.

You got that right. MY 5600 is NEVER going anywhere. But I need the 4wd for snow work, work in the muck etc. My biggest issue with the newest tractors are all the electronics involved in them. Yes, it improves fuel efficiency etc, but I don't like having to wait for someone to come troubleshoot a modern system. I like pulling out the manuals and fixing it myself. All these "sensors" that'll shut you down seems like a great system to get people to buy new tractors every few years.

 

[farmall 55a case]

If he was to get one id say he would like it because it almost twice the tractor he has now!

 

[Bigfoot62]

You got that right. MY 5600 is NEVER going anywhere. But I need the 4wd for snow work, work in the muck etc. My biggest issue with the newest tractors are all the electronics involved in them. Yes, it improves fuel efficiency etc, but I don't like having to wait for someone to come troubleshoot a modern system. I like pulling out the manuals and fixing it myself. All these "sensors" that'll shut you down seems like a great system to get people to buy new tractors every few years.

Those old x600 series Fords are the best. :thumbsup: (see the 2600 in my sig?)
I understand your concerns about the electronic engine controls. I wonder about that myself. And, only time will tell.
I also understand your need for a MFWD tractor with a FEL. They're "handier than pockets on a shirt."
Some people are fine with an "economy" tractor. And, like you, they have a dependable old "beast" for the grunt work. And, if I had a need for an economy tractor, it would be a NH or JD because of the dealer support.