JD 2520 comprable

[ricko54]

Hello,
I was looking at the JD 2520 and was wondering for comparison, what is the comparable size in the Kubota series?
Thank you

 

[duroc]

Hello,
I was looking at the JD 2520 and was wondering for comparison, what is the comparable size in the Kubota series?
Thank you

There are a lot of differences between the two tractor's specs, but based on Engine HP and PTO HP the JD 2520 is comparable to the Kubota B2620.

 

[fordmantpw]

duroc is correct. I've recently compared both of them side by side, and while the HP specs are very close, the JD is a tad bigger tractor (longer, taller, heavier).

 

[ricko54]

Thanks guys. Going into retirement, I'm kind of looking for my last tractor. We have two acres of which about 1 is lawn. A big garden that is a distance from the house. My only tractor is my JD 212 lawn tractor which is all of 30 years old. I was looking for something with a front bucket that I could use for moving black dirt and bark, hauling produce from the garden to the house, as well as moving some snow in the winter. Something big enough that I could put a tiller on in the spring and fall to do the garden. And a belly mower to do the lawn with. The lawn does have some trees to go around, so its not all straight cutting. There will be some maneuvering. I was thinking of a turf tire. I was considering a smaller tractor, but the thing I'm finding is that there seems to be a point when you go from a lawn tractor with small implements, to something a little more husky. I have a friend who does have a smaller Kubota with a front bucket and belly mower that he uses to cut his lawn with. He uses the bucket to move dirt, fire wood etc. I noticed that his bucket is all warped out of shape. Not that he hauls boulders in it, but it just seems to be flimsy weight steel construction. So I'm trying to get past that line where you have a yard toy, to something more respectable that can do a good days work without all the wear and tear on the tractor. Hope this description makes some kind of sense to ya! Rick

 

[Bundi]

Great sight that allows you to do basic comparisons. I Have been comparing the 2520 and 2920 (Dealer didn't have a 2620 on the lot.)

TractorData.com - Tractor Compare

 

[Grandad4]

Those two tractors are close enough to be fraternal twins if it weren't for the paint! The green one may be a bit larger in some dimensions, but the orange one has a slight edge in some performance measurements, such as lifting capacity on the 3 point and on the loader. However I always say going just by those spec sheets is not a good way to choose a tractor for two reasons:

a) It's way more important that any tool feels and works right for its owner, even one as big as a tractor. That's a highly personal thing and what makes something preferable to one of us may be a complete turn-off for someone else. What difference does it make if one tractor lifts 100 lbs more than the other if you're struggling with controls that don't work smoothly and comfortably for you? Check out the operator station and controls, how each one runs and works; eventually your own judgement will guide you in making a choice.

b) Also, just like you don't drive your car at top speed in the real world... it wouldn't last very long if you did... you shouldn't expect to run your tractor full tilt boogie all the time either. Size your equipment so you can use it most of the time at, say 80% or less of its full capability. That goes for pto power, lifting power at either end, pulling power, etc. Your equipment will be safer and last longer and you'll have something in your back pocket for those unexpected situations. If your work ends up demanding 100% maximum performance from your tractor 100% of the time, well, you probably need a bigger tractor.

The one significant operational difference between the two tractors is the 2630 has a 3 range transmission; the 2520 has only 2 ranges. Most owners indicate that middle range is pretty handy since it allows you to stay in one range for most routine work.

The Kubota does have a slightly heavier bucket than the JD; I've not seen a flimsy bucket on any recent Kubota models.

Either make is world-class in quality and holds its value. Couldn't lose with either one, and you should also consider some the other brands also; there are many good tractors to choose from.

 

[duroc]

I too was looking at both those tractors, but ended up buying a New Holland T1510 because after test driving/operating it for about 45 minutes I liked how it fit me better than the others. The NH also has 3 ranges, a standard heavy duty bucket, mid-PTO as standard equip, yad, yada, yada, and it fits through my garage door w/o folding down the ROPS. I bought it at Willards Tractor in West Branch, MI. and they continue to advertise 0% financing. I'm really pleased with my choice.

Grandad4, Made some good points to consider. One of them being that there are many good tractors to choose from. Good luck with your choice, and let us know what you do buy.

 

[MessickFarmEqu]

The one significant operational difference between the two tractors is the 2630 has a 3 range transmission; the 2520 has only 2 ranges. Most owners indicate that middle range is pretty handy since it allows you to stay in one range for most routine work.

worth its weight in gold! Every tractor should have this. I'd like to see it creep down into sub compacts yet.

 

[fordmantpw]

worth its weight in gold! Every tractor should have this. I'd like to see it creep down into sub compacts yet.

Agreed! That is one thing that I REALLY wish the JD 2520 had.

 

[yelbike]

One extra thought may be to skip out on the mmm and splurge for a ztr. You'd be surprised that the price difference isn't all that much more. I bought the jd z465 and mower about 7 acres. Much faster then the tractor, plus it keep the hours down quite a bit.

 

[fieldnforest]

Don't forget about yanmar. I know the sx3100 isn't comparable in horsepower, but based on how you would be using the equipment I think it would be the best match for you, and more comparable to those models you mentioned, based on features. Otherwise if you wanted to compare on horsepower the ex3200 and ex2900 are more comparable.

http://www.yanmartractor.com//index.php?cID=147

 

[fordmantpw]

Don't forget about yanmar. I know the sx3100 isn't comparable in horsepower, but based on how you would be using the equipment I think it would be the best match for you, and more comparable to those models you mentioned, based on features. Otherwise if you wanted to compare on horsepower the ex3200 and ex2900 are more comparable.

http://www.yanmartractor.com//index.php?cID=147

Underneath the skin, the Yanmar SX3100 is the same as the JD 2720, and same as the 2520, just with 5 more HP.

 

[ovrszd]

worth its weight in gold! Every tractor should have this. I'd like to see it creep down into sub compacts yet.

Yep, my old Kubota B2910 had 3 ranges. I did most work in mid range. Low range was very handy for tedious tasks or hard pulls.

 

[fieldnforest]

Yep, and the best the best part is.. no green middle man markup buying the sx3100. If you want three ranges go with the ex3200.

 

[fordmantpw]

Yep, and the best the best part is.. no green middle man markup buying the sx3100. If you want three ranges go with the ex3200.

If only I could get a price quote on an SX3100! 4 dealers, and not a one has given me a trade-in price yet! When they do, I doubt they will beat the JD price as of now. JD is throwing in an extra $1k cash back if you are trading a B or BX series Kubota. If you want resale value, though, you have to admit that JD will hold the value better than Yanmar.

As far as the EX3200, it doesn't come with a mid-PTO (at least that is what my research has told me).

 

[fordmantpw]

Just got the call back from the Yanmar dealer...they don't want to sell one. $18k difference for an SX3100 with my BX2200 trade. JD dealer is $12k for a 2720. Make your own conclusions on how much the green middle man takes...

Sorry, back to the original post's topic.

 

[yelbike]

Curious......why don't you sell you tractor yourself? Typically they buy your tractor at wholesale rate and sell you your new one at retail rate. Again just curious.

 

[fordmantpw]

Curious......why don't you sell you tractor yourself? Typically they buy your tractor at wholesale rate and sell you your new one at retail rate. Again just curious.

I have thought of that, and have seriously considered it (I normally do that with my stuff as I can save money that way). The problem is, I think it would be tough to get out of it what the dealer is offering me. I have cut through all of the crap that goes along with trading (list at retail, show that you are getting EXCELLENT money for your tractor), and when it comes down to it, I would have to get $7500 or more for my Kubota to break even with what the dealer is giving me. JD is offering an extra $1k for trading in a Kubota right now, and the dealer is passing that on to me. Honestly, I was shocked with the offer.

 

[fieldnforest]

You asked for a comparison, so I just told you what I know. I love my yanmar dealer here in wisconsin. He tells me the truth and doesn't play games.
It sounds like a great deal you'll be getting, just make sure you ask them if that is the bottom dollar. NO freight and setup and NO other special sales gimmick charges.
As far as the price difference; you got to make sure when you're shopping around you don't just shop around for tractor price. You need to shop around for the financing. For example, it makes a very big difference if you skip the dealer financing, trade in incentive programs, etc. Just cut to the chase and ask for the cash price, and don't let the dealer jerk you around.
The prices you were quoted have to be apples to apples. Was one cash price and the other 0% for 60 months or some other dealer finance program, or both cash price?
I hope that makes sense.
Good luck with whatever you decide!

 

[fordmantpw]

You asked for a comparison, so I just told you what I know. I love my yanmar dealer here in wisconsin. He tells me the truth and doesn't play games.
It sounds like a great deal you'll be getting, just make sure you ask them if that is the bottom dollar. NO freight and setup and NO other special sales gimmick charges.
As far as the price difference; you got to make sure when you're shopping around you don't just shop around for tractor price. You need to shop around for the financing. For example, it makes a very big difference if you skip the dealer financing, trade in incentive programs, etc. Just cut to the chase and ask for the cash price, and don't let the dealer jerk you around.
The prices you were quoted have to be apples to apples. Was one cash price and the other 0% for 60 months or some other dealer finance program, or both cash price?
I hope that makes sense.
Good luck with whatever you decide!

I wasn't the one that asked for the comparison...I wasn't the original poster.

But yes, I understand all of that. After agreeing on the final price, if a dealer tries to add other charges, I turn and walk if it wasn't part of the original discussion. I was willing to walk out on a truck deal two years ago because they wanted to add a $50 doc fee.

Thanks for the help! I don't want to clutter up the original poster's thread, but I when through with the purchase of the 2720 today. Just waiting for the mower deck to come in, then I will sign papers and it should be delivered next week.