John Deere 5075e verses 5075m

   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #11  
I'm with AKfish, I'd go with the bigger tractor and in the M series. 1,600hrs a year doing PTO work is a lot. I'd want the cushion the larger tractor would offer and the best cab I could buy. :)
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #13  
The M is a much better deal. Around here there are lots of E's unsold but an M is quickly snapped up. The market says "M".
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #14  
Brett, if I am wrong I sincerely apologize. My best friend bought a 2015 5100e. According to Tractor Data.com it was made in India as is the 5085e. Like I said I don't want to provide bad information. If you google any tractor Tractordata.com will come up and give basic information. It seems to me like when I told my friend that has the 5100e that it was made in India he confirmed it. I'll ask him again today. I thought you had to get into the M series to get a new JD made in America. If tractordata.com is wrong, which is possible I'd like to know as I use that for a reference a lot. Again sorry if I was wrong.

I gotcha. I know for sure the 15-17 are assembled in Georgia. I thought the earlier ones were too but I don't have one so can't confirm. I know my 17 is because it just came in on a truck from there!

I've had my fill with India built tractors

Brett
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #15  
I gotcha. I know for sure the 15-17 are assembled in Georgia. I thought the earlier ones were too but I don't have one so can't confirm. I know my 17 is because it just came in on a truck from there!

I've had my fill with India built tractors

Brett

Well.. We're all waitin' and holdin' our breaths for those pictures! Let's see what a 2017 looks like!!
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #16  
Well.. We're all waitin' and holdin' our breaths for those pictures! Let's see what a 2017 looks like!!

Me too! Just got off the phone with the dealer and it'll be tomorrow afternoon before I can pick it up. I have my 5055e all loaded and was waiting on the call. He said that the 3rd function comes with a new guard to protect it and they were missing a stud or something and the parts for the single point hyd for the loader were ordered a little late since I switched to that the other day. I'm ready for it to be here, grass isn't ready to cut just yet but I want to just be able to look at it!

Brett
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #17  
Me too! Just got off the phone with the dealer and it'll be tomorrow afternoon before I can pick it up. I have my 5055e all loaded and was waiting on the call. He said that the 3rd function comes with a new guard to protect it and they were missing a stud or something and the parts for the single point hyd for the loader were ordered a little late since I switched to that the other day. I'm ready for it to be here, grass isn't ready to cut just yet but I want to just be able to look at it!

Brett

Good move on the single point connection! You're gonna like that. Looking forward to seeing the latest 3rd function hookup... New guard setup?? Hmm.
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m
  • Thread Starter
#18  
Gentlemen, I thank you for all your input on 5075e verses 5075m. Now I m more convinced to go with M. I spoke with a JD mechanic shop foreman the other day whom has helped me for the past 17 years with mechanical problems with my 970 JD, he is telling me that the new emissions tier4 is troublesome . Too many sensors that can shut tractor down to 1000 rpm. Can be something minor or something major. Laptop has to be hooked up to figure out problem. That spells down time whether I take it to the shop or get tech out to job site. Any input ?
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #19  
Gentlemen, I thank you for all your input on 5075e verses 5075m. Now I m more convinced to go with M. I spoke with a JD mechanic shop foreman the other day whom has helped me for the past 17 years with mechanical problems with my 970 JD, he is telling me that the new emissions tier4 is troublesome . Too many sensors that can shut tractor down to 1000 rpm. Can be something minor or something major. Laptop has to be hooked up to figure out problem. That spells down time whether I take it to the shop or get tech out to job site. Any input ?

Yes, your statement has merit.

The limited performance that you mentioned is commonly called "Limp Mode". The computer senses what it diagnoses as a hazardous, destructive situation. Rather than let the engine perform normally until this problem magnifies, it limits performance. Most times this is an rpm limit. Some times it is an rpm limit plus a gear selection limit, if computerized transmission is present. Might only function in 1st gear for example.

Not knowing your age, I'll use myself as reference (65).

My early cars had carbs and a point system ignition. Only three tools and a pack of gopher matches was required for a quick tune up. Straight screwdriver, Phillips screwdriver, pair of pliers, gopher match cover to use as feeler gauge. Before a Saturday night street/drag race I have many times tweaked the point setting and timing slightly to get a hotter run. Wouldn't start for crap because was timed too fast. But sure ran good for the few minutes I needed it to.

Today's cars can be tweaked in a similar fashion. Doesn't require any tools. Just a Laptop computer with the appropriate program installed.

Old cars could almost always be made to run with a few minutes under the hood.

New cars can almost never be made to run with a few minutes under the hood.

Which is/was better?

Computerized operation has moved into the tractor market in thanks to EPA. Requires technical input to make diagnosis/repair. Requirement for such intervention is rare. Very rare. For every tractor owner here on TBN that has a horror story concerning this technology there are 100 owners here that will testify to never having the need to have their tractors worked on. I hauled my new tractor home 4 1/2 years ago. 1200hrs later it's never had a dealer repair of any kind required. No malfunctions, no computer glitch, no failed parts.

I've said this before and I'll stick with it now. Use tractors long enough and you will own an emissions tractor. No escape from that fact. I dread the use of DEF more than the possible problems with it. :)
 
   / John Deere 5075e verses 5075m #20  
Final Tier IV seems to have fewer problems than interim Tier IV. Having DEF seems to be a better situation than a tractor with Diesel Particulate Filter - DPF and EGR - exhaust gas recirculation... (Don't you just love all those acronyms!). Biggest concerns seems to be - what happens when the tractor has 4000+ hours and you have to replace the SOC and the DOC - selective oxidizing catalyst and diesel oxidizing catalyst.

Today's cost is somewhere in the neighborhood of $7,000-8,000!

As ovrszd stated, the new tractors, trucks, all have it! If you're looking at a new machine - you will have a DEF tank!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2003 Big Tex 10PI 16ft. T/A Pipe Top Utility Trailer (A49461)
2003 Big Tex 10PI...
71052 (A49346)
71052 (A49346)
2020 Kubota Sidekick RTV-XG850 (A47384)
2020 Kubota...
2009 International Frazer Bilt X-514 Ambulance (A49461)
2009 International...
New Mahindra 8100 CLGC Euro Loader (A50774)
New Mahindra 8100...
HAMM SMOOTH DRUM ROLLER (A50854)
HAMM SMOOTH DRUM...
 
Top