Modular or stick built, what's your flavor?

   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #21  
I know exactly what you are going through Andy. We lost our house to fire September 28. Like you, we are blessed. No one was home when the fire happened and we were able to save most pictures. As we've told people, the four of us were OK, the firemen didn't get hurt fighting the fire, we got our pictures, and other than that it is stuff. We'll get new stuff.:) We were able to go back in and get a few things, but ended up still throwing most of it away as it was either melted or rusted or we were afraid of it because we didn't know how hot it had been and didn't want to take a chance.

We had a double wide/modular whatever you want to call it. It was a nice house with 2x6 walls and good insulation, but there were some things about it that we didn't like where they skimped. When we started looking again we looked at everything available be it modular, a mass builder, a custom builder that did multiple homes at a time, and finally individual/custom builders that did one at a time. Modulars had a BIG STRIKE against them as we just had a cousin that had built a 300k one and had tons of problems. So much so that they ended up suing and got all of their money back. Needless to say, we were skeptical of going down that road. We finally ended with a custom builder that typically is doing 3 - 4 homes at a time. They had plans that we liked well enough to start customizing and we felt we could trust the builder. Ironically the builder we chose we almost walked out about 15 minutes into the conversation, didn't like "what he was telling us." But after listening to him a little bit more we understood where he was coming from and he wasn't feeding us a line of bull just to tell us what we wanted to hear. This had to do with a house layout that my wife found at another builder and was "set" on getting, but I didn't like the looks of the house. He basically was saying what others said that he couldn't "build the other builders house because of copyright laws and ethically he wouldn't." He was able to take one of his plans and take the kitchen layout that she really like and adapt his plan with that kitchen/dining room/great room layout with just enough of a tweak that it is ours and not the other builder's.


Currently we are living in our driveway in a 14x70 trailer that insurance rented for us. Let me tell you this thing doesn't even come close to what our "double wide" was. But at least we are on our property to "protect" our garage and we can see our new house be built. They dug the basement last Monday & Tuesday, poured the footer Friday, yesterday they installed the footer drains and dry well for the sump pump. I'm assuming today they will start installing the forms for the basement walls.

You are moving much faster than we did if you already know a layout. We took about 6 weeks to get a layout and builder. 2 weeks to close because of the Thanksgiving Holiday and then we got held up a bit because of the weather. Hang in there it'll be alright. BTW, our goal is to move in before Monica's birthday - June 1st. They said 4 - 6 months and we are expecting/preparing for the long and hoping for the short. Just to compare, we ordered our moduler August 1, 1999. We moved in November 1, 1999.

BTW, I plan on letting the builder do everything except wire TV, Phone, and Computer. Monica and I are also going to do the painting but we are having the trim stained at the mill based upon advice from the builder.
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor?
  • Thread Starter
#22  
Holy smokes Jim, that first paragraph of yours is eerily familiar. We took out 3 pick-up truck loads of stuff and threw away 2 of them.

I'm not worried about copyright laws. There are enough subtle changes that can be made. Anyway, I lost my house, what can they do to me. Take away my birthday?

The engineer is coming tomorrow morning to inspect the foundation to see if it is usable. If it is okay, we'll probably do the modular. If not, probably stick built.

Modular dealer told us 6 weeks from order to delivery. Now even figuring for some issues, I would plan on 8 weeks. I'm not the type to go screaming after 6 weeks and 1 day. Like I said, I don't think it matters which way we go. It's nothing but a giant headache.
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #23  
Let's not forget the most important factor that pretty much determines everything, the ability to get a loan from the bank. I bought a modular home a few years ago and the banks I dealt with would not let me be my own General Contractor.

I suspect with the mortgage mess of today, the banks have tightened up their lending practices.
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor?
  • Thread Starter
#24  
Money is not an issue. I have a check on the way for $114,000+
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #25  
Here is my take, both are good, you may have problems with anything, have you talked to someone who has just had a new house built in a subdivision? Most have problems or issues.

Modular homes are NOT what they used to be, if you think about they come from a factory [the Mrs. has a point] where conditions are near perfect, there is consistence, i can't imagine corners getting cut, you will get everything you asked for.

Wayne you are right, you do need to watch what people do, and you need to trust them when you are not there [this is really important] My brother inlaw and sister had a new furnace and a/c installed from a large department store it was about $10,000 Well they installed a different a/c it turns out the salesman was on the take and trading off expensive unit for not so expensive units. Good thing my brother inlaw was paying attention. My point is as you know you have to pay attention to what ever you go with.
Stick has obiously been around for a long time, but don't be afraid of new technology, I bet if you went through a tour of a Mod house and no one told you how it was built you would never know.
Sips are great but expensive.

Good luck and make sure you get a good sized garage with it.:)


Shane
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #26  
We built with a mix of manufactured & stick-built. The usual response when people walk in the front door & are then told the house arrived on trailers is "No! Really?" Actually what you see is 2 "homes" tied together: Left side is around 1250 sq ft, right side is just under 1000 sq ft, between is utility room (stick built), garage & car port are also stick built. Manufactured homes DO have their issues, but then so do most stick built homes, they're just different. We've had our issues, but the vast majority of them are directly related to the incompetent GC & the subs he hired. We also set the whole thing on a "Superior Walls" foundation so we have a full, insulated, basement.
 

Attachments

  • MVC-01S.JPG
    MVC-01S.JPG
    26.2 KB · Views: 246
  • MVC-035S.JPG
    MVC-035S.JPG
    29.8 KB · Views: 198
  • dartatfarm3.jpg
    dartatfarm3.jpg
    53.9 KB · Views: 208
  • house-1.JPG
    house-1.JPG
    150 KB · Views: 189
  • flowers-1.JPG
    flowers-1.JPG
    148.7 KB · Views: 177
  • flowers-2.JPG
    flowers-2.JPG
    146.4 KB · Views: 181
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #27  
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor?
  • Thread Starter
#28  
cmhyland said:
What about building with SIPs ( Structural Insulated Panels ) very fast, super strong and you can heat the places with a match.

I know you didn't mean anything by it and I did laugh a little when I first read it, but I'm putting this house up because mine burned down on Nov. 28.
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor?
  • Thread Starter
#29  
Dartman, that's a nice place you have there. Half modular and half stick. Were you looking for a problem? I equate that to being married and having a girlfriend. One woman is enough of a headache, I don't need 2.

I hope those garages are filled with old Mopars.
 
   / Modular or stick built, what's your flavor? #30  
There are some very nice modular houses. Once you start adding all the upgrades like high ceilings, 2x6 walls, etc... the price is not much different than stick built. But you get it done very fast compared to stick built.

If you are having a basement under it, get an engineer to spec out a steel beam to run the length of the entire basement. That way, you have a completely open basement. They have to bring out a crane to set the house anyway, so have them set the beam, too. Save a bit of money.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2014 Therm Dynamics TD400 Towable Flameless Heater Trailer (A49461)
2014 Therm...
2016 VOLVO VNL TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A51222)
2016 VOLVO VNL...
2014 VOLVO VHD (A50854)
2014 VOLVO VHD...
American Sanders EZ-8 Electric Floor Sander (A49461)
American Sanders...
Landoll (A50657)
Landoll (A50657)
2024 Case IH Magnum 380AFS CVX Connect MFWD Tractor (A50657)
2024 Case IH...
 
Top