Power-trac v. cut

   / Power-trac v. cut #1  

jfdlaw

Silver Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2004
Messages
156
Location
Webster, NY
Tractor
Kubota 2410
I posted this on the general buying/selling forum, but got little response. Thought I would try it here.

<font color="blue"> I need some input.

I've been looking at tractors for about a year. We have 13 acres of hills and trees surrounding our house. We have a 400 foot level driveway and an old dirt road leading to the recreational portion of our property. The road goes down a hill that covers about 130 feet of elevation over 650 feet of length. I have a Polaris ranger that will handle all but the few steep parts in two wheel drive.

I want something to do:
- FEL work, loading & spreading mulch, probably a grapple bucket to pick up the limbs, brush etc.
- snowblower. It snows alot around here.
- some grading with either a blade and/or a backblade. There are some high spots on the dirt road I would like to knock down and ruts I would like to fill.
- Once or twice a year I rent a chipper to get rid of the brush and limbs, and thought about buying a PTO unit, but its not that hard visiting the local rental yard.
- I leave the lawn cutting to others, so that is not a priority.

My concern is that there are projects I want to do down the hill, off the level ground. I don't anticipate doing work on hillsides but I will have to get the machine up and down the dirt road and will do some work while on the slope.

I came very close to buying a Case DX40 (NH TC40D twin) last month. (Some last minute pressure from the dealer turned me off) I was also seriously considering a Deere 4410, but got distracted by the Case. I now think that given my hills, and the fact that I won't be using the rear pto/3pt hitch much, a power-trac might be a better answer.

One of the neat things the Case featured was a "quick attach" on the FEL that mates to skid steer type attachments. The ability to run standard skid steer implements was a big part of the attraction to the Case. The power trac offers similar ability to change front implements, but they are all proprietary, you can't use standard skid steer attachments. I'd rather be able to use standard attachments.

One part of me likes a CUT like the Deere or the NH/Case with big comfortable operating areas, standard connections and local dealer support.

The other thinks the Power-trac is better on the hills and probably better suited for the tasks I want to perform.

I'm thinking about a PT-1430. I think I'm going to visit the factory in a few weeks

Let me know what you think. Thanks.

</font>
 
   / Power-trac v. cut #2  
Welcome to TBN! /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

I'm sure you will get some very good advice. We're always willing to spend someone else's money! /forums/images/graemlins/smirk.gif

</font><font color="blue" class="small">( One of the neat things the Case featured was a "quick attach" on the FEL that mates to skid steer type attachments. The ability to run standard skid steer implements was a big part of the attraction to the Case. The power trac offers similar ability to change front implements, but they are all proprietary, you can't use standard skid steer attachments. I'd rather be able to use standard attachments.
)</font>

You make it sound like you believe that Case is the only manufacturer that offers the quick attach feature on the FEL. I just wanted you to know that I believe that every manufacturer offers this kind of option.

I'm not knocking Case or Power-Trac. They're both very fine machines. I'd just hate to see you miss getting information about other possibilities so that you can make the most informed decision. Certainly the Power-Trac would be able to accomplish all of the tasks that you've identified. But as you noted, the attachments are proprietary. Having a "standard" type of attachment system, you'd have the ability to purchase only what you absolutely needed, and then you could rent other attachments on an as needed basis.

Good luck with your search. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
   / Power-trac v. cut
  • Thread Starter
#3  
I understand I can get a similar "quick attach" fitting on other tractors, it wasn't the only reason I was looking at the case. They also have a neat system for front blades and snowblowers and I simply like driving the 35/40/45 series NH/Case Machine.
 
   / Power-trac v. cut #4  
For the money, the PT1430 is the handest tool I have ever bought. It's my favorite PT. Thru the years we have put lots of hours on most CUT's, tractors, crawlers, and mowers out there. Now we are only using six PTs. For all around work, easy to repair and good value, in my opinion, PT beats all others. Buy the correct size for your job, or strain the guts out of a small unit.
EB
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

71059 (A49346)
71059 (A49346)
40ft Shipping Container (A49461)
40ft Shipping...
2016 Big Tex 14LX 14ft 7 Ton T/A Dump Trailer (A50322)
2016 Big Tex 14LX...
2014 KENWORTH T800 MIXER TRUCK (A50854)
2014 KENWORTH T800...
New Kivel Single Skidloader Spear (A50774)
New Kivel Single...
2014 VOLVO VHD DAYCAB (A50854)
2014 VOLVO VHD...
 
Top