patrick_g
Elite Member
Well... I did see one PEX failure involving properly installed materials. One of the finish carpenters drilled holes in the slab floor to put in "blue screws" (Tapcon) to anchor a newel post for the banister railing. He didn't pay close attention when told where not to drill and hit a PEX run in the slab for hydronic heating. Had to get a demo hammer and chip out the floor at the site of the oops and repair with crimped fittings. No problem, all is fine now. It was not the fault of the PEX and no fittings failed.
I have used two kinds of crimp rings, the ones that look like a tarnished copper wedding band and the stainless steel ones. I prefer the stainless steel because the crimpers for them fit multiple sizes and the others require a separate dedicated crimper for each size and they aren't cheap.
One thing I do avoid now is copper tubing for water lines. I have seen two MAJESTIC failures of that: 1. a run in an attic to get to an ice maker on opposite side of the kitchen from water supply. and 2. copper tubing inside a plastic tube to protect the in-slab run from chemical attack by the concrete.
In the first case the tubing ran across ceiling joists and for no discernible reason developed a pin hole that resulted in all the ceiling Sheetrock falling down or needing replacement and two carpeted rooms had to have the carpets taken up as they were saturated. The pin hole was just spraying a fine mist but over time while the homeowner was away for a week the damage was considerable.
In the second case the copper tubing developed a pin hole leak for no discernible reason. The copper tube was inside a plastic tube to protect it from the concrete slab. Anyway the plastic filled and overflowed at the lower end which happened to be in the wall behind Sheetrock. I had to use my tractor to pull the copper out of the plastic tube. I replaced the copper with PEX which went in pretty easy as it was only a 10 fr run with few bends.
I no linger trust copper tubing to carry water in a location out of sight.
Patrick
I have used two kinds of crimp rings, the ones that look like a tarnished copper wedding band and the stainless steel ones. I prefer the stainless steel because the crimpers for them fit multiple sizes and the others require a separate dedicated crimper for each size and they aren't cheap.
One thing I do avoid now is copper tubing for water lines. I have seen two MAJESTIC failures of that: 1. a run in an attic to get to an ice maker on opposite side of the kitchen from water supply. and 2. copper tubing inside a plastic tube to protect the in-slab run from chemical attack by the concrete.
In the first case the tubing ran across ceiling joists and for no discernible reason developed a pin hole that resulted in all the ceiling Sheetrock falling down or needing replacement and two carpeted rooms had to have the carpets taken up as they were saturated. The pin hole was just spraying a fine mist but over time while the homeowner was away for a week the damage was considerable.
In the second case the copper tubing developed a pin hole leak for no discernible reason. The copper tube was inside a plastic tube to protect it from the concrete slab. Anyway the plastic filled and overflowed at the lower end which happened to be in the wall behind Sheetrock. I had to use my tractor to pull the copper out of the plastic tube. I replaced the copper with PEX which went in pretty easy as it was only a 10 fr run with few bends.
I no linger trust copper tubing to carry water in a location out of sight.
Patrick