"Within a month the thief was caught. Turned out to be a nearby resident* in the lake community who made a pretty good living stealing from summer folk."
Sadly it seems that most lake communities suffer the same ailment, I know we do.
Last summer they hit 9 chalets stealing anything sellable at pawn shops or yard sales.
In our case even stoves, and other furniture. Seems they had a moving van.
They were brazen enough to actually have camped in one house.
Naturally all booze also 'evaporated'.
Over the years I personally have been responsible for causing the arrest of 5 perps.
Very satisfying. (LOL, neighbors awarded me a plastic toy 'Police' badge)
Today most of our residents have a monitoring system of one kind or another so crooks beware.
* same here. A local gets to know the routines and the safe times. Usually fall after 'back to school' and never if any snow around. (leaves tracks)
But we learn.
Have a gate? don't close it as that indicates you are away, leave it open.
Retrieve the trash bin, if by the road they know you are away.
Leave a curtain open, one that has nothing of value within eyesight. If a perp sees a flat screen, VCR and booze he'll for sure break in but if nothing of value you might get passed up.
I know of some that even leave an old non functional car parked within view simply to suggest they are home.