This has been a record hot summer and as I get older I find the heat more exhausting. So I'm going to air condition my workshop. It's 20X30 and well insulated. It will maintain a temp of 75 - 80 with the doors closed. As it has no windows I am getting a through the wall unit.
After looking around the internet and reading reviews I settled on a Frigidaire unit at 12,000 BTUs. Ordered it from Amazon. It arrived today. Looked good on the outside. Opened the box and all the Styrofoam was destroyed. The side is dented in and the other side bowed out, as well as one sprung screw. I sent Amazon a Return Request. I was also unhappy to discover it is made in China! Now I'm waiting to hear back (48 hours)
So I'm back on the quest.
Any experience with this type of project, I'd appreciate your input.
Putting a window unit in a wall can lead to a lot of issues with water getting into the wall. Flashing that opening has to be perfect because window units create massive amounts of water that typically drips out the back of the unit, and onto the ground below. This leads to termites and other bugs, along with mold and mildew if the water isn't addressed.
Split systems are an affordable option to an entire house system, but significantly more expensive then a window unit. Nothing is cheaper then a window unit!!!
If it was me, I would look into adding a window to the wall.
If adding a window isn't an option, I would still go with a window unit over a split system because of the cost. I've also never been in a room with a split system that I felt was as comfortable as a whole house HVAC system. When I walk into a room, or small house, that uses a split system, it's noticeably warm and muggy feeling to me. Not that dry, cool air that I prefer. Window units do a fantastic job of drying out the humid air, and if left running, they keep a room nice and cool too. You just have to get one big enough for the room, and have the power available for it. Some require a 30 amp 120 volt outlet, which is very rare in any house or shop. 20 amp is more common, but it's also best if it's a dedicated 20 amp outlet.
Two years ago I had a new Amana HVAC system installed in my house and I was told it was the only brand made in the US. My HVAC guy said that he toured their plant and was impressed with their quality control. Everything was tested, over and over again. I don't know if they build window units there or not. They sell Amana window units at Home Depot, but I've never looked at them. I have found that Home Depot will sometimes be cheaper then Amazon. Especially when shopping online and having it delivered to the store for pickup.
Amana - Window Air Conditioners - Air Conditioners - The Home Depot