LBrown,
I disagree with your assessment about the solely garden tractor motif on the X series. JD markets them as garden tractors, but they do have much more capability than any garden tractor I have ever used or seen. These machines are capable of doing real loader work, though the loader is slower than that on the 2305. In my area, many landscapers use these machines in place of ZTR's for rapid mowing, spraying and tillage work. They are more comfortable and have better ergonomics than does the 2305 for mowing type work and thus are a great choice for those tasks among landscapers here who mow on the steeps yet have to do some ground engagement or snow removal work also to do. This makes them both popular and unique and keeps them moving at a rate similar to the 2305 here. I would agree if I (meaning ME personally) were looking at a machine in this size, I would go with a 2305, but if I were a landscaper or commercial mower who did not want a ZTR I would go with the X series, in the four wheel steer. This is what many are doing in my locale. I will also say that some dealers, mine included, think the build quality and finish work on the X series machines is better than the 2305. Although I have never seen a poorly made 2305, I am sure there is some validity to this point as the X series machines are really nicely made--and cover a niche, especially in four wheel steer varities--not covered by the 2305 or other SCUTS.
John M
