Best Home Defense Rifle?

Status
Not open for further replies.
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #91  
For all you Annie Oakley types

I've got to ask, what is an Annie Oakley type?

Is it

A. Someone who is a good shot?

b. Someone who wears womans clothes?

I'm also guessing that the "jist" of the off topic conversation is that a "rifle" may not be the best weapon for self defense inside the home.
 
Last edited:
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #92  
Another vote for a shotgun. Any rifle is poor in a home because of how it will go through many walls. Be a bummer to lose everything because you took a shot at someone and killed the neighbor 200 yards away...or someone in the house that's more dear.
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #93  
Funny, one year at home we went out shooting (after he had been in the Marshall service for a number of years) and he got to shoot my Glock.

That's interesting. A friend of mine from college is a U.S. Marshal and has been for many years. For at least the last decade or so the standard issue sidearm for a U.S. Marshal has been Glock pistols. They have a specific list of choices for backups, but they are issued Glocks. He told me that the producers of the movie U.S. Marshals, made in 1998, did actually check with his agency to get their sidearms correct in the movie so the famous line from Tommy Lee Jones "Get yourself a Glock. Get rid of that nickel plated sissy pistol" when he was talking to Robert Downey Jr. would sound accurate. What years was your relative a U.S. Marshal when he never had an opportunity to fire a Glock pistol?

Glocks are generally considered a great progression of a revolver which, of course, don't have safeties on them. As far as what agencies opt for what sidearm, this website is relatively decent to use for reference http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/leiber/50/DGAAAFED.html
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #94  
That's interesting. A friend of mine from college is a U.S. Marshal and has been for many years. For at least the last decade or so the standard issue sidearm for a U.S. Marshal has been Glock pistols. They have a specific list of choices for backups, but they are issued Glocks. He told me that the producers of the movie U.S. Marshals, made in 1998, did actually check with his agency to get their sidearms correct in the movie so the famous line from Tommy Lee Jones "Get yourself a Glock. Get rid of that nickel plated sissy pistol" when he was talking to Robert Downey Jr. would sound accurate. What years was your relative a U.S. Marshal when he never had an opportunity to fire a Glock pistol?

Glocks are generally considered a great progression of a revolver which, of course, don't have safeties on them. As far as what agencies opt for what sidearm, this website is relatively decent to use for reference http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/leiber/50/DGAAAFED.html

You know Brent, I took that out just for the fact that I didn't want you to think I was trying to take a jab at you:D

I believe my cousin got out of the U.S Marshall service when I got down to N.C which would of put it after the year 2001.

His primary carry piece was a Sig P220, which he picked up after he moved from Philly to "down south" (well over 15 years ago).

I do know that my cousins primary duty was to capture wanted felons "out in the field", something which he apparently was pretty good at. His point on the Glock was that in a stressful situation, he did not like the "trigger action" on the Glock when he had the gun pointed at someones head (which apparently he did very often) because his finger was usually on the gun's trigger (and yes, we all know your finger is not supposed to be on the trigger until the exact moment you're ready to shoot).

My cousin did have the opportunity to discharge the Glock, that's one reason why he didn't want it. I also won't tell you what he said about that movie, because I'm sure it would be deleted here anyway.

That said, didn't know many LEO's or Fed's who carried A Taurus, like Downey's characted did in the movie.

Right before I left FLA a young officer was involved in the arrest of a man. The officer had his Glock out and was not watching the muzzle. Mistake 1 since the pistol was pointed at the arrestee's head. The arresstee reared back. Mistake 2 was the officer's finger on the trigger. Pistol went bang. Arrestee went dead. Would a DA/SA pistol have prevented the accident vs a Glock? Who knows but it was a point of discussion. The officer got out of law enforcement.

Actually Dan, you kind of "proved" my cousins point as to why he didn't care for the Glock.
 
Last edited:
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #95  
My case in point was not to find fault, but use an example of what happens when you have live ammo, your finger is on the trigger and your blood is pumping "expecting" perhaps to find something bad that can kill you.

Now imagine a "regular" homeowner who goes and investigates a noise with a gun. Thing about the military (since M4's are being used as example on what the military uses) is that you can sometimes shoot first and ask questions later.

I did not use my friends example as a fault finding exercise but as an example of mistakes can and do get made. His mistake, and many that happen in law enforcement, is not taking ones time. My friend did not need to go into that house. He did not need to go alone. In fact the house was just in his jurisdiction. It really was another agencies call but he was closer. The victim was outside and safe. He WANTED the bad guy so he went in.

From what I read about the Wilmington shooting, the officer saw something in the kids hand which was not a weapon. I remember the officer was expecting a violent criminal.

I know of incidents where officers have shot family members in their own houses. The officer heard a noise, got up to investigate and shot in the dark. Killed one of his children sneaking back into the house. The officer shooting his own child did not even know who he was shooting at. He was a dumb .... And he has to live with it the rest of his days.

Using a rifle in the house should be a last resort. Not something I would recommend. Using a rifle against two legged critters outside a house is going to be interesting justifying deadly force. Shooting someone at effective rifle distances and justifying deadly force is going to take some doing.

Glock stuff..... :D

Oh how I tried to avoid Glock's and accidental shootings in the hand gun thread. :eek::D And you HAD to bring this up! :eek::D

I would really like to see accidental discharges rates of Glock vs others. My guess is that Glock will be a bit higher because of the trigger pull and my pet peave with having to pull the trigger to field strip the weapon. My father knows a guy who just shot himself in the hand cleaning a Glock. I don't know the guy but I think he is a retired LEO. Not real sure HOW he shot himself in the hand but he did. I wonder if my pet peave was a part of the chain of events.

Right before I left FLA a young officer was involved in the arrest of a man. The officer had his Glock out and was not watching the muzzle. Mistake 1 since the pistol was pointed at the arrestee's head. The arresstee reared back. Mistake 2 was the officer's finger on the trigger. Pistol went bang. Arrestee went dead. Would a DA/SA pistol have prevented the accident vs a Glock? Who knows but it was a point of discussion. The officer got out of law enforcement.

In MY case the lights would be on so I can see who is who in the house.

Everyone's situation will be different. Some people here on TBN have little to no training. Some people take various types of classes. Other have military and/or law enforcement backgrounds. One had better judge ones skills or lack there of and act accordingly. And act according to the law or Thou Goose Will Be Cooked. And Thee Be The Goose. :eek:

Later,
Dan
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #96  
From what I read about the Wilmington shooting, the officer saw something in the kids hand which was not a weapon. I remember the officer was expecting a violent criminal

Actually Dan, the officer in question saw NOTHING, but heard what he thought was a gunshot, and discharged his weapon through a CLOSED door, striking and killing the "victim".

I think the family ended up getting $2,000,000 for it and the officer in question was terminated from his job.
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #97  
Actually Dan, the officer in question saw NOTHING, but heard what he thought was a gunshot, and discharged his weapon through a CLOSED door, striking and killing the "victim".

I think the family ended up getting $2,000,000 for it and the officer in question was terminated from his job.

What I remember from the initial reports two years ago was that the victim had a game controller in his hand when he went to the door. The officers were at the house with a warrant looking for a violent criminal who had stolen game console(s).

Later,
Dan
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #98  
Well now that we are totally off the OP topic, (best RIFLE to defend a home)
Regarding the best pistol action, If I new I was going to be in a hand gun combat shoot out, be it a LE, military or gangland scenario, I would want my full size Glock .40 hands down, why wouldn't you want the most reliable pistol in the world, accidental discharges aside, it could be the difference between L&D.
JB.
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #99  
I love the mini-14, but also like the 7.62x39. So I have a mini-30 to go with the mini-14. Hi cap mags are available,(for now), and the larger caliber would be a better stopper than a .223. I also like to keep a few daddy's little helpers in handy spots around the domicile. Kind of hard to stash a rifle up and out of the way, but handguns take up little space and are easy to keep out of reach of little fingers. Just make sure that they're close enough to get to in a hurry. Bad times are a'comin. Get what you can now. Also, about the 12 ga. I know for a fact the dread that bad guys feel when they hear the sweet sound of a shell being shucked into the barrel of a gun. Close quarters, shotgun hands down. Grown men pee when looking at the wrong end. Critters in the yard, (2 and 4 legged), rifle, easily hidden are the handguns. Keep a few handy. There is no one best bet, so cover all the bases you can. I know I do.
God Bless (and help) America.
Pat
 
   / Best Home Defense Rifle? #100  
If I had an extra money that I could use to buy something fun and useful, I would get a mini-14.

However, the Russian designed 7.62's(particularly the SKS, but pick one that fits the budget) are very robust, easy to use, cheap, and have cheap bulk ammunition available for them.

I have seen sks's for less than 100$, with ammunition less than 12c/round. I agree that people who don't know how to shoot should not think about shooting, and having moderately priced ammunition available for practicing is very useful for learning how to shoot.

Also, SKS's are FUN to shoot, and would be very effective for the resistance of organized thuggery, if one knew how to use them. Mini-14's give you the same effect, but at a significantly higher price for consumables.

I think the significantly more expensive guns(AR-15s, AK's, etc), don't provide enough incremental benefits to outweigh their costs and complexity.

SKS's can also be used for hunting mid-sized game(I think, though I have never done so), where the 223 rifles cannot.

Chris
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2005 Isuzu NPR Venco VC516 Landscape Dump Truck (A50323)
2005 Isuzu NPR...
John Deere 6410 Loader Tractor (A50514)
John Deere 6410...
2014 MACK GU713 WATER TRUCK (A51243)
2014 MACK GU713...
2017 Dodge Grand Caravan SE Van (A50324)
2017 Dodge Grand...
2016 BOBCAT T590 SKID STEER (A51242)
2016 BOBCAT T590...
2004 IC Corporation 3000IC School Bus (A51692)
2004 IC...
 
Top