After reading the entire thread, and understanding what you are trying to do, I will give you my insight. Unfortunitly I do agree that it sounds like you just really want a 550. If you already have your 350 for going to the lumber yard, and plowing snow, do you need another?
I have a GMC3500 SRW set up with a utility body, lumber racks, etc, so 5th wheel is out of the question. It doesn't have a plow. I like it that way. It's a really sweet truck and I don't want to plow with it. I need the 550 (or whatever truck I decide) to tow long trailer, plow snow, spread salt and do other contracting work.
Also as soon as you drop that GN into your bed, no more sheets of plywood on the way home.
I had no plans of doing both at the same time, but it can be used to carry materials when it's not towing. Of course lots of materials could go on an unloaded trailer, too. It's more versatile than a road tractor because it has a bed on back. That's why it appeals to me. A road tractor can never carry plywood, unless it has a trailer attached to it.
You would still have to go home and drop the gn, so you could switch trucks......Have you ever pulled a 30-35' gooseneck? I doubt it would be any easier then your current setup (dump w/ tag)
Oh it's much easier. I have towed with one, as well as other longer trailers behind tri-axles I used to drive (I used to work for an excavator and I was the one with the class A that drove the tri that towed the 955, excavator, etc.) A 30' gooseneck is a breeze to park and has much better visibility and manueveribilty than my current backhoe trailer.
All of the rigs mentioned are going to be about the same length, and are going to be a PIA to run and get things during the day unless you drop your trailer.
You think a 550 is a PIA to run & get things? I owned a F-450 for 7 years and I thought it was very similar to driving a pickup truck!!
I totally understand your want for the does everything truck, but honestly that is extremely hard to do. I've been there and done that, my daily driver is in my garage with the 9' door, and my truck is in the barn......Does your dump fit into a 9' o.h. door? Can you pick up your boy from pratice in that? can you throw 50 sheets of plywood in that? In my opinion, a better tag is the best bet for now......You have some hard decisions to make, good luck....
OK, thanks.
My dump needs a 10' door. I have no plans to run errands in it. Just too much truck for that. The reason I want to get a smaller truck is so I don't have
2 trucks of limited use. I could probably put 500 sheets of plywood in my dump. The 550 is nice because it'll easily tow the gooseneck trailer, it's nicer to drive than a crude dump with a tag, I can plow snow or run errands with it and it fits in a smaller garage. I have other aspirations with this truck, too. might haul some equipment for others for moderate distances.
My gosh, if guys like Hawk are pulling similar equipment behind a 1-ton DRW pickup, wouldn't a 550 be as good or even better?
I do appreciate your suggestions-don't want you to think I'm blowing them off. The longer tag is a great "economy" solution, but truthfully, I need another truck anyway and a road tractor wouldn't be practical unless I was doing more business, like LCB. Maybe in the future, but not now or the next couple years. I can always trade for bigger.
Here's my dump. Looks nicer now. I added rear Alcoas, new cab shield, company decals, etc. I couldn't imagine driving it 300 miles with a farm tractor & bush hog in tow on a regular basis.
