Maybe I missed something in this thread but I recall Piston said his box blade was leaking down........in his pics of the unit it shows his cyl is a pull cyl, so that to me would mean his cylinder rod is drifting out when the box blade is "leaking down" (his words)......He never said the cylinder was drifting in (IIRC)
The same setup as most bucket/tilt cylinders on FEL. If the piston seal or a check ball was not pressure tight on the piston head it would drift out like Piston said......so Yes his problem was directly the check/valve ball if it was off the seat......maybe that curl was a piece of a spring that got mashed between the hyd rod and the cyl base