Shame on dealer!

   / Shame on dealer! #1  

oscarvan

New member
Joined
May 22, 2020
Messages
13
Location
Bethlehem, PA USA
Tractor
Mahindra EMAX 20S
So..... Got her home yesterday, and there was fluid on the deck under the steering wheel.
It was clear and felt like water and not oil or hydraulic fluid so I attributed it to wash water blowing out on the road at 65mph.

Today, however, after 10 minutes of mowing my admittedly lumpy yard there was more. So
this time I confirmed what it was..... Have you ever tasted battery acid? Not my favorite. So,
I removed the screen and found the battery badly leaking from the caps. After removal it turned
out it was seriously over-filled. Fluid should be at the bottom of the necks, it was more than
halfway up. In the attached pictures you can see the amount of fluid I removed from this small battery
to bring it down to the proper level, and that's AFTER a bunch of it leaked out, and the damage done to the battery tray and surrounding area.

I've cleaned it up and painted it, so I'm good, but it made for a somewhat frustrating "first day" especially
since this was 100% human error and preventable. Someone needs to have a chat with the tech that
prepped this unit for delivery. And yes, I sent this story to the dealer.

After that I mowed my entire property (with no more fluid coming from the battery) and must say I am pleased with the performance. I took off the
backhoe and FEL for maneuverability and that was as easy as in the videos. Good stuff. It's a keeper.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_7425.jpg
    IMG_7425.jpg
    2.4 MB · Views: 235
  • IMG_7426.jpg
    IMG_7426.jpg
    4.1 MB · Views: 224
  • IMG_7429.jpg
    IMG_7429.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 209
Last edited:
   / Shame on dealer! #2  
Yes Indeed. Some dealers have so poorly trained mechanics ...its incredible. Most Dealers seem to be just fine on maintenance and repair issues. But nearly every tractor owner can relate some type of horrendous mistake by service departments.

In my case, I brought my tractor in for a small warranty repair. While there i was feeling guilty about such a small repair, and asked them to do additional engine oil/filter change and hydraulic fluid/filter change. I go to pick up my tractor. After paying the bill, i checked the repair, and then checked all fluids....and wow there was not a drop of engine oil or hydraulic fluid in the tractor. None. They checked also to confirm. None. Embarrassed, they explained what happened, the mechanic drained all fluids, changed all filters just before lunchtime. After lunch he simply logged everything completed, and parked the tractor.

I made them bring all the fluids to the tractor when they filled it with oil. Lesson here is: 1. always check your fluids and 2. Any service you can do yourself, is probably better for your tractor than a dealer doing it.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #3  
Yes Indeed. Some dealers have so poorly trained mechanics ...its incredible. Most Dealers seem to be just fine on maintenance and repair issues. But nearly every tractor owner can relate some type of horrendous mistake by service departments.

In my case, I brought my tractor in for a small warranty repair. While there i was feeling guilty about such a small repair, and asked them to do additional engine oil/filter change and hydraulic fluid/filter change. I go to pick up my tractor. After paying the bill, i checked the repair, and then checked all fluids....and wow there was not a drop of engine oil or hydraulic fluid in the tractor. None. They checked also to confirm. None. Embarrassed, they explained what happened, the mechanic drained all fluids, changed all filters just before lunchtime. After lunch he simply logged everything completed, and parked the tractor.

I made them bring all the fluids to the tractor when they filled it with oil. Lesson here is: 1. always check your fluids and 2. Any service you can do yourself, is probably better for your tractor than a dealer doing it.

I would pay money to see somebody “park” a hydrostatic tractor with no hydraulic oil in it.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #4  
I would make sure you clean the radiator real good........................
 
   / Shame on dealer! #6  
would make sure you clean the radiator real good........................
I was thinking the same thing, lots and lots of baking soda to neutralize the acid, although whatever damage has been done by now.................Mike
 
   / Shame on dealer! #7  
Yes Indeed. Some dealers have so poorly trained mechanics ...its incredible. Most Dealers seem to be just fine on maintenance and repair issues. But nearly every tractor owner can relate some type of horrendous mistake by service departments.

In my case, I brought my tractor in for a small warranty repair. While there i was feeling guilty about such a small repair, and asked them to do additional engine oil/filter change and hydraulic fluid/filter change. I go to pick up my tractor. After paying the bill, i checked the repair, and then checked all fluids....and wow there was not a drop of engine oil or hydraulic fluid in the tractor. None. They checked also to confirm. None. Embarrassed, they explained what happened, the mechanic drained all fluids, changed all filters just before lunchtime. After lunch he simply logged everything completed, and parked the tractor.

I made them bring all the fluids to the tractor when they filled it with oil. Lesson here is: 1. always check your fluids and 2. Any service you can do yourself, is probably better for your tractor than a dealer doing it.

Felt my blood pressure rise just reading this..
That mechanic should have been given a permanent lunch break.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #8  
"So
this time I confirmed what it was..... Have you ever tasted battery acid? Not my favorite."

:eek:
 
   / Shame on dealer!
  • Thread Starter
#9  
I was thinking the same thing, lots and lots of baking soda to neutralize the acid, although whatever damage has been done by now.................Mike

Afraid so. Hosed it all down liberally. Baking soda is caustic. Also not your friend. Dilution is the best thing.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #11  
So, battery placement in front of the radiator and battery acid pooling on the platform under the steering wheel means that everything under the hood got wet down with acid! As stated, wash it down well, neutralizing with baking soda, pray corrosion doesn't get a foothold in components and wiring connections.
Pure incompetence on the tech's part.
Unfortunately, new equipment setup and oil changes are usually assigned to the new guy in the shop, especially when senior techs are busy with bigger jobs.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #12  
If this is a new machine, I wouldn't have touched anything. I'd have made the come and get it and bring another one.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #13  
Felt my blood pressure rise just reading this..
That mechanic should have been given a permanent lunch break.

More than likely the high school drop out did the prep and the mechanic did higher value billable work.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #14  
I would make that dealer immediately replace the tractor OR give me a written guarantee to repair each and every thing that goes wrong with it down the road. Because of the reverse cooling (from dash to the front) EVERYTHING has been coated with that acid mist...EVERYTHING. Unless you submerged that tractor, I wouldn't trust it for long-term survival.
 
   / Shame on dealer! #15  
if you keep this tractor read post 10 again.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Adams Under Truck Conveyor (A56438)
Adams Under Truck...
2015 Dodge Journey Van (A59231)
2015 Dodge Journey...
2022 WEILER S350 SKIDDER (A60429)
2022 WEILER S350...
2014 Kia Sedona Van (A59231)
2014 Kia Sedona...
2008 MAXX-D FUEL TRAILER (A58214)
2008 MAXX-D FUEL...
PALLET OF 15 4X8 GROUND PROTECTION MATS (A58214)
PALLET OF 15 4X8...
 
Top