Time to replace the tires on my 325D Groundsmaster. The tires on it had been filled with foam and have developed a flat spot... bumpety, bumpety, bump. I use my machine to clear snow from my asphalt driveway, and probably not ever much else, though I really enjoy seeing what Xfaxman has done with his! I use rubber tire chains for traction and to keep from tearing up my asphalt. (
Rubber Tire (Snow) Chains - Traction without damage.) A couple of questions:
1) which tires would you recommend I get? Currently have turf tires.
2) anyone have them filled? Foam? Beet juice? I've got an Ag Tire Dealer within 50 miles and thinking about having them do the work.
3) ? Please help me understand everything I don't know here
Thanks!
I'm just now catching up... so I might be late in answering, as I work my way up through the posts.
I have ran three sizes and two different tread patterns.
1st option: standard size 23x8.50x12 Carlisle turf tread (can't remember specific design)... PROS: decent traction, less scuffing in turns, noticeably smaller tread width in aftercut appearance CONS: most defined tread path in aftercut appearance, least uphill traction, least flotation in wet areas OVERALL: best option for operating in flat areas... if using a turf tread tire, this one will likely have the best traction when using the snowblower/snowplow.
2nd option: Toro's optional "up size" (standard on later models, I believe) 23×10.50x12 Carlisle turf tread PROS: better flotation in wet areas, lower ground pressure, less defined tread area in the aftercut appearance (albeit wider), noticeably different ride (more bumps, but less exaggerated), better uphill traction, noticeably more stable, better sidehill grip CONS: more prone to scuff in tight turns, or when turning uphill OVERALL: my experience was better with the wider tires... however, the ride was considerably different. The wider tires picked up more bumps, and they seemed sharper and more firm than the "bounce" or "floating" ride of the 8in tires. The best way to describe it, is what was previously a half-second "bounce" became a 1/10th of a second "jolt". NOTE: When I bought this mower, it came equipped with these tires in 2-ply configuration. They rode better, but I've yet to see any 2-ply tire rated for the weight of this mower, and my manual specifically addressed this issue with a warning to only use 6-ply tires of appropriate load rating.
3rd option (currently installed): Carlisle 24×12×12 6-ply "AT101". This is a "chevron" or "bar" tread tire... similar to an "ag" tread, but much less exaggerated, with rounded edges on the outside. PROS: MUCH BETTER traction in all conditions, best flotation, best sidehill stability CONS: WORST for scuffing while turning tightly or uphill, picks up more bumps than any of the other options OVERALL: In my applications, it just works better... but the ride took some getting used to... ESPECIALLY downhill handling. You would think a simple 1inch larger diameter wouldn't change much... if anything, it should raise the fulcrum point, putting better weight transfer to the back axle. If you're not careful while operating with these tires, they can do more harm than good (scuffing turf, off-loading the rear axle going downhill, or simply increased traction getting you into more precarious operating conditions [steeper slopes, etc.]) In short, these are the most capable tires you can buy, but require a bit of added attention while operating. These tires WILL NOT clear the OEM return spring for the brakes. My brakes were DOA, so I simply removed the springs. If you're brakes are functional, you can buy a cheap set of 5-lug spacers to resolve the issue.
4th option (haven't used... yet): 24×12×12 turf tires... they will fit... but more than likely will also require spacers, if the wheels aren't appropriately backspaced. SPECULATIONS: more bumps, but more stability and traction... chains will cost about the same (if not less) because it's a more common size than 23×10.50. Replacements will be more readily available, as this is also a more common size found on commercial zero turn mowers. 12 inch wheels are also more readily available. The Carlisle "AT101" tires I mentioned above, were sourced from Rural King, pre-mounted on new wheels, for $105 a piece ($210 for the pair). If you figure in the cost of valve stems and wheels, that was a steal.
5th option: "budget", "off-brand", or "china" tires. In my opinion, the worst option. As Xfaxman and I have discussed previously... they just don't last like they used to. The rubber is typically of lower quality, and a harder compound. You may this harder would last longer... but it doesn't (ask me how I know). The tread edges get rounded, and they lose traction with most of the tread remaining... then they dry rot, crack, or simply delaminate. Some guys swear by Kenda... I think I've even seen them on a couple of Xfaxman's units.... but their bar pattern is too sharp on the edges for me, and cut into the turf too much. If you live on the flats, not a problem. If you think about going near a ditch or embankment, expect turf damage.
Again, this might be late... but it's my experience with the issue. Hope it helps!