Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?

/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #1  

bp fick

Super Member
Joined
Aug 15, 2009
Messages
5,697
Location
Beaver Creek, Northern Michigan
Tractor
John Deere X390
Hopefully, an interesting story.

Bought my BX (at a good price) 10 months ago. It was perfect in every way, but then, quite unexpectedly, I got a huge (for me) contract for organic foods production that I had not anticipated when originally purchasing. In order to row cultivate more mature plants, I intended to step up to a B2320. It's higher clearance would allow me to straddle the plants up to 12" in height, something the BX cannot do.

Called a couple of friendly dealers, even reached out to a few who hang out here, but trading in a 10 month machine would mean a beating I wasn't willing to take. Listed it, along with the front hydraulic plow and QH on a few sites. This was during the February snow events from coast to coast. The phone rang off the hook about the front blade and sold it easily for what I had paid for it, $1750. A guy drove up from Ohio and grabbed it. With some patience, I also agreed to sell the tractor to a fella who had seen the Craigslist and came over and we agreed on a price, about half way between what I had paid and what was being offered to trade in. I was quite satisfied. He put down a hefty deposit and followed up with the cash. Said he'd pick up the tractor in a "few weeks", which was fine with me. He didn't seem like the "tractor type", if you know what I mean and I remember thinking he was buying a bit on impulse, but, hey!, who was I to question it?

So I commenced shopping prices and availability of a B2320. I didn't particularly enjoy what I was hearing, but was committed and so the process continued. This "switch" is going to cost and the wife was somewhat grumpy about it, as she liked the BX.

A couple of weeks have passed by without a word from my buyer. Finally, I called him. Turns out he had been transferred with his work and was trying to figure out the shipping costs and arrangements. (west coast) Fine. He told me if I needed to use the tractor, by all means do so. Sure, why not? So, I used it move the camper and boat out of the barn, re-worked the new garden field. Hey, why not?

This morning, he called. (you gotta know what's coming next) He wanted to know if I would consider buying the tractor back.

What? Did I hear him right? He said it was going to cost him "an arm and a leg" to transport it and his company would not pay for it, as it was not considered "household goods". And that if I would buy it back, he'd eat a grand. My first thought was that laying out that money he had likely emptied his pockets and was now fairly hungry for cash. I told him I'd think about and get back to him.

I've told the wife and she said immediately that she just as soon have the BX back and not have more debt nor a larger machine, as she didn't feel as comfortable on it in tight quarters. Interesting. She asked if there was a way to work around the cultivation issue.

Well, that's where it stands right now. Do I or don't I? Do I really nick him for some funds for this deal, or not? Hmmmm...
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #2  
Hey BP
Take the deal he offered you, it's not your fault for what has happened to him since he made the deal to buy the BX. It will help you to replace the implement that you sold.
Good Luck
DGS
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #3  
I would show up on his doorstep certified check in hand with no hesitation as it is an arms length transaction before anyone else gets to him!!!!!!
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #4  
Let your concience be your guide on your question but I am more concerned about you getting nicked here...I assume you gave him a bill of sale..so if I were you since this buyer came from Craig's List and we have all heard the horror stories of scams from there, I would be sure to paper your file...be sure all of the money he gave you is collected funds if a check was involved for part of it and then be sure you have paper work first signed by him and mailed ( not faxed ) back to you transferring ownership back to you...This could be just as he said but it is also screwey enough to be a scam that your buyer has concocted...Just a thought..be careful.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #5  
If HE is the one who mentioned that he would eat a grand, I wouldn't be too bashful about complying. You could always suggest that you split it and say $500 or if you in a very generous mood, just send back his original deposit and hope that good karma pays it forward. :)
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Let your concience be your guide on your question but I am more concerned about you getting nicked here...I assume you gave him a bill of sale..so if I were you since this buyer came from Craig's List and we have all heard the horror stories of scams from there, I would be sure to paper your file...be sure all of the money he gave you is collected funds if a check was involved for part of it and then be sure you have paper work first signed by him and mailed ( not faxed ) back to you transferring ownership back to you...This could be just as he said but it is also screwey enough to be a scam that your buyer has concocted...Just a thought..be careful.

brin, nah, good thought, but no. He's a local guy. Know of him, but don't know him as a personal friend or anything.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #7  
I'd take his offer.

From Monday's experience, I sold out 197? Wheel horse C-160 for my asking price in about 3 hours for cash. After I sold it I immediately felt that I had sold something I may regret soon not having. But, it's gone and at this point I am happy about the whole deal.

I would take the "extra" $1k and that should about cover 1/3 on a good 8N or similar older 40hp tractor for the work you need a larger unit for.

If everything goes well for me, I'll have a Jubilee with loader and 8,000# BP trailer for what I got for my Wheel Horse and old Craftsman chipper :)
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #8  
If HE is the one who mentioned that he would eat a grand, I wouldn't be too bashful about complying. You could always suggest that you split it and say $500 or if you in a very generous mood, just send back his original deposit and hope that good karma pays it forward. :)
I like this one the best especially if you want to keep it anyway. Lord blessed you with $500 and he can just as easily let it slip away. Just one mans opinion. Doing someone right always pays and I'm not saying keeping the entire amount is wrong but.........:)
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Don't believe in over profiting by another man's foibles, some of which he did to himself, well.... actually, all he did to himself.

(Agreed, Big believer in knowing my source, let the reader understand.)

That said, people gotta know the art of the deal, take responsibility and so forth. Either way, I will try to do what's right.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #10  
You have a tractor your wife likes and you wanted to sell it. That alone sounds crazy to me.

Send the guy back his $$$ minus the $1000 agreed and consider yourself lucky. You have a tractor your wife likes using and that is worth lots of $$$$. That means she is doing stuff with it while you do other things. That is a good deal!
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#11  
You have a tractor your wife likes and you wanted to sell it. That alone sounds crazy to me.

Send the guy back his $$$ minus the $1000 agreed and consider yourself lucky. You have a tractor your wife likes using and that is worth lots of $$$$. That means she is doing stuff with it while you do other things. That is a good deal!

The issue of cultivation remains a sticky point. I have done this vegetable growing, commercially all my life, sometimes part time, and full time as a youngster. There is a work around, though not a perfect solution. You have to alternate "high" crop with "low" crops, row on row. That way, you are only cultivating the low crops and allowing the outside of the cultivator to work the "high" row. You alternate rows, in other words. It is ok. I just prefer to plant similar plants side by side. They seem to do better next to their own kind.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #12  
Maybe I'm a sucker, but I'd give him a break and let him have his money back except maybe $250-$500. I know its giving money away, be it seems to me he is being pretty fair about it.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #13  
Have you looked into the B2320 at all? Take your wife and test drive one. They drive very similiar to the BX. But.. you are in a tight pinch and a little extra dough is hard to come by these days. I would pray and sleep on that one. Good luck!:thumbsup:
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#14  
Have you looked into the B2320 at all? Take your wife and test drive one. They drive very similiar to the BX. But.. you are in a tight pinch and a little extra dough is hard to come by these days. I would pray and sleep on that one. Good luck!:thumbsup:

Yes, we drove one around the sales yard, thus her feeling it is big, but, of course, it is. She'd adjust, no?

Yup, believe you confirmed my own thoughts. Kinda thought the same thing. Sleep on it. Never hurts.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #16  
Who in their right mind would pay for a tractor on a private craigslist sale and then not take delivery of it right then and there? On top of that, they ok'd the seller continuing to use/abuse the tractor while they were fiddling around for "weeks"? Heck, that's even better than "don't be gentle, it's a rental" since you're not even renting the darn thing. It sounds like this guy was not ready to buy a tractor, or worse yet up to something. I would make sure the check clears if he paid the balance that way (you said "cash" so unless it's counterfeit you're good there). I would then tell him to come pick up his tractor. I'm sure nobody is going to agree with me based on the posts so far to this thread, but unless the buyer/seller are buddies or related this whole scenario is rotten.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#17  
Who in their right mind would pay for a tractor on a private craigslist sale and then not take delivery of it right then and there? On top of that, they ok'd the seller continuing to use/abuse the tractor while they were fiddling around for "weeks"? Heck, that's even better than "don't be gentle, it's a rental" since you're not even renting the darn thing. It sounds like this guy was not ready to buy a tractor, or worse yet up to something. I would make sure the check clears if he paid the balance that way (you said "cash" so unless it's counterfeit you're good there). I would then tell him to come pick up his tractor. I'm sure nobody is going to agree with me based on the posts so far to this thread, but unless the buyer/seller are buddies or related this whole scenario is rotten.

Again, there was no check to clear, other than the original deposit, which cleared just fine. He hadn't made arrangements for it's shedding nor for its transfer. Doubt he even owned a trailer of any kind. Nope, not a friend. "Abuse" the tractor? I don't think so. You are very right about one thing, he wasn't prepared to be a tractor owner, that is for sure. Is his "move" excuse bogus? Who's to say? Just plain old fashioned buyers remorse? Shrug.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #18  
I will say this though. You're a heck of a nice guy to consider buying it back. I would much rather have bought from a seller like you than a paranoid untrusting person like me :)
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860?
  • Thread Starter
#19  
I will say this though. You're a heck of a nice guy to consider buying it back. I would much rather have bought from a seller like you than a paranoid untrusting person like me :)

Well, I did not ask for this, believe me!! To use your word, it does indeed stink. It re-opened all the "stuff" with the wife and all, that was gone over and closed, if you know what I mean? What was to be a simple sale, followed by a time of new machine shopping, has become what it has become. Sometimes life is goofy. Sometimes you just make lemonade.

Nice guy? Yeah, most think so. :laughing: Well, I am actually at peace with it all. I am too experienced (old) to be all hot and bothered. I count my blessings. I thank God for another day of life. Spring is coming, life is good. It will be what it will be. It's hardly the end of the world.
 
/ Do I "un-sell" My BX1860? #20  
I would take his offer and refund his deposit less the $1K. You did suffer some economic harm in that you lost the opportunity these several weeks to find a verified buyer. By his deposit, your were bound not to sell the tractor to anyone else, even if they came with a higher offer.

After that, I would just trade in the BX1860 on the B2320 you're wanting and use the extra $1K to make up for the lower price you'll get trading wholesale. Life is too short, so why go through the hassle of re-posting the 1860 for sale and not have the tractor you really need for your organic gardening when you need it. The wife will come around.
 

Marketplace Items

JLG 20MVL MANLIFT (A58214)
JLG 20MVL MANLIFT...
SWICT 78" SKID STEER BUCKET (A60430)
SWICT 78" SKID...
JCB 507-42 TELESCOPIC FORKLIFT (A60429)
JCB 507-42...
Pittsburgh Heavy Duty Solid Steel Auto Ramps (A59230)
Pittsburgh Heavy...
2018 CATERPILLAR 313FL EXCAVATOR (A60429)
2018 CATERPILLAR...
(2) UNUSED 31" X 10 MM EXCAVATOR TRACKS (A60432)
(2) UNUSED 31" X...
 
Top