Good weld?

   / Good weld? #31  
No, this is a pic from everything attachment. I致e been in the market for a grapple for my track loader. They are very expensive compared to other grapples by 2.5 times. They post pics of welds and I could only imagine theyæ±*e good. But this just looks very uneven to me as you look down the seam.

I find myself just looking at welds on things anymore.

Typical manufacturer squirt gun job. I would not buy that implement. Had one like that on a Kubota attachment, broke first time I used it. No evidence of fusion or penetration on either side. Made them replace.

Ron
 
   / Good weld? #32  
Here is what a Mig weld can do on 3/8-inch thick steel.:cool:
 

Attachments

  • Best.JPG
    Best.JPG
    230.2 KB · Views: 210
   / Good weld? #33  
...and it is so nice to see you back, SA!
 
   / Good weld? #35  
It is very hard to type with one arm! With my on the job brain injury, my right arm does not work! Maybe it will get easier. :thumbsup:
 
   / Good weld? #37  
Well, you come from yer experience base, and truth to tell yer thinkin deficiency anemia is probably normal to dat base.
You go look dat picture I posted where da cake decorator went wild wid de hotglue gun, you see where yer idea 1 little defect don't matter fails ta slice de mustard.
Dat assembly of stukta dat looked pretty started unzipping at weakest spot, and once zipper got movin it all come unstuck.

Looks like dat behind de desk experience never had you up close & personal wid a load gone wild either. Best case de falling load stay in one lump before hits ground and after. Forklift rarely best case. Good way to handle material, but generally material held on pallet by gravity alone. Same bunch number guys you hang wid probably got number splains how a buck worth of shrinkwrap or bands not justifiable due to several factors and dat buck better spent in bonuses. From where you guys sit it makes sense. You on de job site yer experience probably not let you see possibility cube of blocks gonna take down scaffold dat gonna hit something else gonna fly and hit Bob just below hardhat as he comes out of blue wart.

On de good side you do recognize heat signature on de weldment is an indicator of deposit quality. Ain't everything, but it a start on education road. Better picture is probably looking at heat picture as weld is being deposited. Best gonna be cut it, polish it and develop it for true story of penetration. One de worst things bout wire welding is deposit of cake piping can look like good weld. Again, look de picture I posted, piping looked real nice, but separation proves piping not even connected to adjacent piping by nothin but stukta.

Again yer viewpoint on first line manufacture is based on where you lookin from. Big yellow in Peoria shipped hundreds of tons of stukta components since 'engineers' lookin at screens had lunch wid bean counters lookin at more screens and decided MIG is best bang fer de buck. Der track record on hydraulic cylinders alone proves engineers don't know much bout welding. Maybe dey engineered cylinders for maximum replacement.

I'll still stand by my point. every business out there is going to "design" to the need. if the tried and true, proven time after time for decades need is only a 3 on 12 intermittent fillet weld, and someone provides a continuous fillet, then 75% of that weld is excess. if the 3 on 12 need is completely satisfied by a good quality weld, then the rest is mostly irrelevant. if there are a couple sketchy spots in the "bonus areas", it won't do anything detrimental. the key is having a quality weld that satisfies the need. if you don't have a quality weld then it's irrelevant how much you have. if you do have a quality weld, having 4x as much as you need only costs more. if the failure is due to lack of fusion it is irrelevant how it was designed. That's on the guy pulling the trigger, not the guy pushing the keys.
 
   / Good weld? #38  
It is very hard to type with one arm! With my on the job brain injury, my right arm does not work! Maybe it will get easier. :thumbsup:

Good to see you again, Carl. Hope you are able to keep posting!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2024 WABASH STEP DECK TRAILER (A51222)
2024 WABASH STEP...
JOHN DEERE 850J LGP DOZER (A50854)
JOHN DEERE 850J...
2015 FORD F-250XL SUPER DUTY SERVICE TRUCK (A51406)
2015 FORD F-250XL...
2023 FG INDUSTRY STE 35SR MINI EXCAVATOR (A51222)
2023 FG INDUSTRY...
2003 STERLING ACTERRA 11FT FLAT BED (A51222)
2003 STERLING...
2018 GENIE GTH-5519 TELESCOPIC FORKLIFT (A51242)
2018 GENIE...
 
Top