Grapple style preference

[ROUSTABOUT]

We use both. We go clean up after storms. Work for FEMA. #2 is handy outputs couple more hinges on it and they all bend. Easier to fix it while it's straight and new.
I also like the type that hasa solid bottom and the two clamps on top with removable sides on the bucket. Way more versatile. Scoop coconuts, sides on. Load logs, sides off. Just a wax on wax off kind of thing. Bucket solid bottom type is good only if removable sides.

 

[qstott]

I like #1. This is a WR Long OBG. Before I got pallet forks I used it for picking up all kinds of things. Plus, I could hook chains underneath and pick up stuff. Getting up overgrown bushes is a breeze. Just tilt downward, push under the bush and curl up. It pops them right out of the ground. That works for small trees too.I have used it for moving lumber, limbs and such. I’ve never used #2, but there are so many things that I use mine for, that just couldn’t be done with the other style.

 

[iptman]

I have option #2. With my sized tractor I don't think #1 would be as effective. I wanted light weight and and an all around grapple. A dual lid version of this would have been nice but you'd lose a lot of strength. When I was shopping around I saw a lot of manufacturers say not to use the lid to scrape with but EA posted a video basically hanging a tractor by the lid. One of the many things that sold me on theirs.

 

[Grapple guy]

Here is I am using and I haven't found anything it can't do. My tractor is the same size as yours, but you have a bit more HP. I put up 16 cords of wood this weekend with it. I love to build with big rock and I am placing 600 - 900 lb. rocks with it as well

 

[Jac65]

I would (and did) go with choice #3. I use a bucket grapple, or what they call an industrial grapple. the bottom is a solid closed bucket and the top is the open grapple. 90% of the the time this is what stays on my FEL you have the ability to move rocks ,logs, clear brush, grasp and rip undergrowth, and you still have the solid bucket to move material or dig and spread. For me it is the best of both worlds. You might want to consider it as a possible choice depending on your needs.

 

[Xfaxman]

Here is one unusual thing that I did with the #1 "L bottom" root style back in 2014:

Hooked up 4 chains and picked it up:

Drove the truck forward:

And set it on the ground:

 

[charles todd]

I'm trying to decide which style of grapple to get, #1 (root) or #2 (rake/clamshell). I've never used a grapple so I don't have any experience with either style. I've always thought the rake style (#2) would be better, especially for grabbing a big pile of brush. In what situation does each style work better than the other?

Thanks,
JarrettView attachment 713735View attachment 713736

I have one like, #1. Probably had it about 10 years.

CT

 

[bill9068]

I have little to no brush. So I got the rock/root style. Use it for large sections of pine tree trunks and large rocks. Land Pride SGC 1560 and WR Long 3rd function valve. Good idea to modify your grill guard. Protect the grill, radiator and battery from sticks, stobs and limbs.

View attachment 713777View attachment 713778

That is a great job covering that grill. I need to do that.

 

[IndyJay]

Loaded with my small single lid grapple:
View attachment 713808View attachment 713809View attachment 713810

I've got one of the same kind of grapples that you have on the Polaris. A real back saver!

 

[DieselBound]

I've had my grapple for 5, going on 6 years now. EA single lid. Works for me! (my use is varied, as can be seen here in these pics)

Attachments

• 
  512413d1497412907-grappling-fun-picture-thread-img_20170613_145127581.jpg

  7.4 MB · Views: 491
• 
  GrappleWork.jpg

  1.7 MB · Views: 463

I know I'm going to curse myself, but I don't have grill guards on either of my tractors. I have put on a combined 1,800 hrs between the two and I've never driven anything into the front grill. Been close. I have, however, managed to drop stuff on top of the hood on BOTH tractors: B7800 took the hardest hit; NX I was mostly able to pop out (around one of the headlights). I tend to watch very closely as I drive into any brush piles and such. As soon as I dust off my new welder and actually learn to use it I'll look into doing a guard on the Kioti.

 

[neilkingent]

for brush style 2

 

[old and tired]

I'm also choice #3, Bolt on grapple to my bucket so I can deal with Dirt and Gravel. I don't have a SSQA bucket (if fact my bucket has never been off the FEL). I'm sure it could unbolt but I like having both a grapple and bucket.

 

[ruffdog]

I also make do with a grapple bucket.

 

[M59]

I'm trying to decide which style of grapple to get, #1 (root) or #2 (rake/clamshell). I've never used a grapple so I don't have any experience with either style. I've always thought the rake style (#2) would be better, especially for grabbing a big pile of brush. In what situation does each style work better than the other?

Thanks,
JarrettView attachment 713735View attachment 713736

Jarrett,

My personal preference is a version of #2, a Bradco 72" wide root rake on a M59. Wide enough to clean a path the full width of the machine of rocks, roots and brush. The upper and lower jaws open wider than any other available grapple so picking up very large trash piles, logs, root balls, rocks is possible because the tines can reach around very large diameter objects. The open jaw distance between upper and lower tines is greater than 4 feet. See page 2 of pdf for specs.

I never found type #1 to be very useful.

At the end of the day. Buy quality and you will have tool that doesn't let you down. Greese nipples and bushings on every rotating joint, steel shields between what you are picking up and the cylinders and hoses, and a beefy skid steer quick attach mounting plate.

Have fun working your grapple.

 

[Midniteoyl]

Jarrett,

My personal preference is a version of #2, a Bradco 72" wide root rake on a M59. Wide enough to clean a path the full width of the machine of rocks, roots and brush. The upper and lower jaws open wider than any other available grapple so picking up very large trash piles, logs, root balls, rocks is possible because the tines can reach around very large diameter objects. The open jaw distance between upper and lower tines is greater than 4 feet. See page 2 of pdf for specs.

I never found type #1 to be very useful.

At the end of the day. Buy quality and you will have tool that doesn't let you down. Greese nipples and bushings on every rotating joint, steel shields between what you are picking up and the cylinders and hoses, and a beefy skid steer quick attach mounting plate.

Have fun working your grapple.

While nice, and I agree with the 'hybrid' type grapple, that one would leave him with only ~200lbs of lift capacity left.

 

[mikester]

I have the root rake #2 style which works fine for pushing out trees and shrubs but I wish I had #1 for moving wood and brush. #2 can't carry many logs.

 

[oosik]

Primary reason I choose rock/root grapple. Bottom tines are much heavier. Won't crumple when dealing with large rocks and trees.

 

[bud70706]

I'm trying to decide which style of grapple to get, #1 (root) or #2 (rake/clamshell). I've never used a grapple so I don't have any experience with either style. I've always thought the rake style (#2) would be better, especially for grabbing a big pile of brush. In what situation does each style work better than the other?

Thanks,
JarrettView attachment 713735View attachment 713736

I'm trying to decide which style of grapple to get, #1 (root) or #2 (rake/clamshell). I've never used a grapple so I don't have any experience with either style. I've always thought the rake style (#2) would be better, especially for grabbing a big pile of brush. In what situation does each style work better than the other?

Thanks,
JarrettView attachment 713735View attachment 713736

I'm trying to decide which style of grapple to get, #1 (root) or #2 (rake/clamshell). I've never used a grapple so I don't have any experience with either style. I've always thought the rake style (#2) would be better, especially for grabbing a big pile of brush. In what situation does each style work better than the other?

Thanks,
JarrettView attachment 713735View attachment 713736

I use a Rhino similar to design 2 on a JD 3046R. I move a LOT of brush, logs & limbs I chip. Probably my most used attachment.

 

[Hay Dude]

I like the adjustable forks on bottom for prying out rocks, lifting pallets, or logs. On top, I like a single or double arm. I went with a single-less expensive and tends not to get in the way on irregular objects. This log weighed well over a ton on the butt-ometer and the HLA single arm held it easily.

 

[TractorGuy]

Whichever one you get you will find times the other would work better.

I have #1 and there are times I would like #2.

Either one will beat none and you will be glad you have it.

Type 1 will handle a pile of brush fine.