TomSeller
Super Member
Not a skid steer grapple but it served well for the purpose I bought it for, but to your point, a narrow grapple with properly sized tines and single lid is the bomb.
Grappling fun - A Picture Thread....
- Thread starter Piston
- Start date
- Views: 633477
Not a skid steer grapple but it served well for the purpose I bought it for, but to your point, a narrow grapple with properly sized tines and single lid is the bomb.
I keep hearing about the superior breakout force of these narrow single lid grapples but most of them have long tines. I'd rather have a wide grapple, dual lids, and shorter tines. Plus how much does a couple of extra tines on a grapple reduce breakout force.
Jim Timber
Veteran Member
I find most of my breakout force is generated by my wheels when using the grapple. I push trees over, then hook their roots and if I can't pull them out with the lift or curl, I'll push on the bottom edge of the root ball again with the whole force of the tractor. Once I get a tree past 45 degrees, it's coming out whole.
dragoneggs
Super Star Member
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2013
- Messages
- 13,627
- Location
- Seabeck, Washington
- Tractor
- Kubota BX-25D, Kubota Z122RKW-42
I just want a dam grapple!
Jim Timber
Veteran Member
If I can't get it to budge with the hydraulics, I'd rather have the cylinders locked by the spools and acting as solid links than working against the pressure relief valve.
JMO
4570Man
Super Star Member
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2015
- Messages
- 18,335
- Location
- Crossville, TN
- Tractor
- Kubota M59, Kubota L3800, Grasshopper 428D, Topkick dump truck, 3500 dump truck, 10 ton trailer, more lighter trailers.
A no lid grapple Is definitely the worst.
OP
Piston
Elite Member
I simply can NOT understand, why some people just continue to push a single style grapple just because it's worked for them and they're circumstances. There is one person on this forum who has tirelessly persevered to convince people that one standard single lid 48" grapple is the best just because it works for 99% of his situation, then there are a handful of followers to jump on the wagon to back it up. It's as if it's just a convenient way to enter into a debate, and no matter what the subject would be, these people would debate just for the sake of it.
I'm really trying to keep this thread from becoming "just another" grapple debate thread. There are plenty of those.
Guys, if one piece of equipment works for others, why does that bother you SO much? Why do you just HAVE to point out that a different piece of equipment can do the same job? If I have a wider grapple with 2 lids, and it works for me and my circumstances, so what? If you are happy with a narrower grapple with one lid, then so what? I'm happy for you that you can go out there and be proud of a job you've accomplished using what you have. Why do we have to try to convince each other that what works well for us, is better for you?
I would like to keep this thread on track. I don't think we need to constantly repeat the same thing that has been repeated over and over on this forum.
Ideally, we can all just be happy that each of us is contributing photos to this thread, whether it's a bucket grapple, heavy duty grapple not ideally situated to CUT's, a giant loader grapple, excavator grapple, who cares.
If nothing else, let's agree to disagree, there is nothing wrong with that. But let's please just keep the discussion about "what grapple is better" to the other hundreds, if not thousands of threads on TBN.
Now, I know I'm not a moderator or anyone who is any more important than anyone else on this forum, so I have no right to tell anyone what they can and can't post, I'm just asking out of respect for the original intent of this thread, to please follow the request posted in the very first post of this thread.....
I'm really trying to keep this thread from becoming "just another" grapple debate thread. There are plenty of those.
Guys, if one piece of equipment works for others, why does that bother you SO much? Why do you just HAVE to point out that a different piece of equipment can do the same job? If I have a wider grapple with 2 lids, and it works for me and my circumstances, so what? If you are happy with a narrower grapple with one lid, then so what? I'm happy for you that you can go out there and be proud of a job you've accomplished using what you have. Why do we have to try to convince each other that what works well for us, is better for you?
I would like to keep this thread on track. I don't think we need to constantly repeat the same thing that has been repeated over and over on this forum.
Ideally, we can all just be happy that each of us is contributing photos to this thread, whether it's a bucket grapple, heavy duty grapple not ideally situated to CUT's, a giant loader grapple, excavator grapple, who cares.
If nothing else, let's agree to disagree, there is nothing wrong with that. But let's please just keep the discussion about "what grapple is better" to the other hundreds, if not thousands of threads on TBN.
Now, I know I'm not a moderator or anyone who is any more important than anyone else on this forum, so I have no right to tell anyone what they can and can't post, I'm just asking out of respect for the original intent of this thread, to please follow the request posted in the very first post of this thread.....
I found myself posting a bunch of pics of my grapple over on another thread, and realized I love posting pics of it, so I figured I would start a thread for grapple pics.
I'll try to post more and more pics of my 'grappling fun' as time goes on. However, since it seems grapples are getting more and more popular and people are using them for more and more jobs, I encourage anyone else to post your "grappling fun" pics as well :thumbsup:
Only rule of the thread.....no arguing about what type, make, size or anything is better/worse....
OP
Piston
Elite Member
Duplicate....
Last edited:
mrtwister
Bronze Member
Well put Piston.....that whole debate does get tiresome for those of us who are here to simply view grappling photos......I raise my glass to you roposetoast: twister
roposetoast: twister