What if we had to spend under $1000? Cause thats the top end of the budget. New only, I can't tell how many hours are on a used compressor, so used is a big unknown. Sure, they can be rebuilt, but I would have to factor that into the price up front. My Puma looks brand new but is 25 years old and has run many hours.
I am 54 years old, so need compressed air another 20-25 years. My Puma single stage cast iron v-twin lasted that long, so I am hoping for a repeat.
I am assuming I would get 20 years lifespan out of the IR, since it is larger capacity than my Puma single stage. If noise is the only objection, I have the option of installing it in a building separate from my shop, and about 24 feet away. The more I think about this idea, the more I like it. There is 100 amp service in that other building too, so the compressor could be on its own power (separate from my workshop 100 amp service, both buried direct to the pole-mounted transformer). Air distribution is not a big problem, since I was going to distribute inside the shop anyway, and was contemplating taking a line over to the other building. So I would be doing all the same plumbing for distribution, but the compressor location would switch from one to the other building.
That other building is not heated, so I would have to make sure I was running synthetic compressor oil. It will have to start at as cold as 10 below zero I assume. Guess I better ponder that concept a while longer...
Meanwhile, I plan to call the local TSC store and ask the manager to run over and read the motor information plate on the IR to me, so I don't have to drive down there. And I will look at my Puma motor plate information tonight too.
IF I go over budget somewhat, this Quincy looks like the closest to compare without going crazy overkill:
FREE SHIPPING — Quincy Compressor Reciprocating Air Compressor — 5 HP, 230 Volt Single Phase, Model# 2V41C60VC | 19 CFM Below Air Compressors| Northern Tool + Equipment
I noticed they use a cast iron crankcase and an aluminum head. I havent really had great luck with that combination of materials in automotive applications. They give the pump rpm as 1310, and list it as splash lube.