I have two towns about half hour from me that each have Lowes, Home Depot, and Menards. I usually go south and have settled on Menards 95% of the time. HD has gotten more of my business recently due to the great selection online because they ship for free or to the store for free. Last night I went north to that cluster of the 3 stores. I was in them all, and found the experience to be nearly identical to their stores when I go to the town south of me. Lowes was a ghost town, with employees avoiding eye contact and scurrying away so I had to find things on my own. HD was a little better, with a cleaner store that was better stocked and organized. One employee asked to help me. Still the store was nearly empty. Then on to Menards. Employees approached me several times asking if I needed anything. (when Menards opened, it was mandatory for employees to ask customers to assist them, and then mandatory for them to walk you to the item you were looking for rather than just say "it's in isle 9" ) The store is bright and clean. I bought a wide variety as usual, including Howes Diesel Treat, epoxy, treated lumber, 20' sticks of rebar, bacon, eyebolts and turnbuckles, dog food, and I special ordered a sheet of walnut plywood. I checked out and picked up this week's rebate form to get 11% credit on the purchase. They also have scanner stands around the store so you can price check items if they aren't marked. Oh, and they have an Ap for your phone, so you can look up items and the Ap will show you the approximate area to find it in the store. The Ap also has a built in price scanner option so you can point at bar codes and get the current price. I love that place.
My wife and I went to the other cluster of these 3 stores a couple nights ago. First Menards where we found they are wrapping up a makeover and expanding the areas. They also have new LED lighting that is extremely bright now, which is nice for my tired old eyes. This store had well over 100 cars in the parking lot as usual. Unfortunately Menards only carries trim molding in 8' and 12' lengths, and not nearly as wide as I needed so they got no sale to me. Next was Lowes, where there were less than 10 cars. Their trim area was sparse compared to what it used to be, and they didn't carry any wider trim and most was 12' or less. Too bad since this is where I bought the original trim, 10 years ago, that I was trying to somewhat match. On to HD. Maybe 20 cars, but they had a much better selection of trim, in wide widths and 16' lengths. Well stocked and organized too. They get my business this time. It is nice to have a choice of all three stores within a couple miles of each other.