LS?

   / LS? #1  

coloradotrout

Gold Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2005
Messages
390
Location
Eastern KS
Tractor
JD 4100 HST CUT w/Yanmar 3TNE74 | JD 300 Lawn
I am looking for a 30 to 40 hp with fel to replace my Deere 4100 hst.

Want the 2 pedals. Need the same reliability.

Hobby farm brush cutting, 5 ft tiller for garden and horse arena, box blade & angle blade for road maintenance, 5 ft finish mower for 2 ac lawn.

4100 does everything ok except tilling and moving round bales.
 
   / LS? #3  
My LS is just over 2 years old with almost 300 Hours And has ran great and did all the jobs I needed it to do.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#4  
Got a dealer 2h away so going to research. Any suggestions on model?
 
   / LS? #5  
I am looking for a 30 to 40 hp with fel to replace my Deere 4100 hst.

Want the 2 pedals. Need the same reliability.

Hobby farm brush cutting, 5 ft tiller for garden and horse arena, box blade & angle blade for road maintenance, 5 ft finish mower for 2 ac lawn.

4100 does everything ok except tilling and moving round bales.
Depending on the weight of the round bales, You are looking at a MT2 40 minimum.

But would suggest looking at the MT3 series and even the MT4 series if you are moving a lot of round bales and they weigh over 1800 lbs.

This may be the ideal one for you
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Depending on the weight of the round bales, You are looking at a MT2 40 minimum.

But would suggest looking at the MT3 series and even the MT4 series if you are moving a lot of round bales and they weigh over 1800 lbs.

This may be the ideal one for you
That's definitely on the high end of what I'm thinking. $25K max spend is also what I'm thinking. While being able to handle heavy bales would be great I'm not sure that's the mainstream of what I'll be doing. I also need to finish mow 2-3ac and some of that is on a slope. I also like the smaller size to get into tight places. We'll see.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#7  
Called the LS dealer. MT240HE is where he suggested. Maybe MT235, but felt the extra 5 hp is money well spent.
 
Last edited:
   / LS? #8  
My Yanmar YT235C has 123 hours no problems
and also has a 10 year warranty drive train

willy
 
   / LS? #9  
Called the LS dealer. MT240HE is where he suggested. Maybe MT235, but felt the extra 5 hp is money well spent.
I was looking hard at the MT225HE and went with the MT235HE for the extra 10 HP. Came at the cost of emissions control garbage, but I sure like the extra power. I would think the same would be true if you bumped to the 40HP.
 
   / LS? #10  
The 240 will gain you heavier loader with more lift capacity. I have an XG3135 (bought used) and it's beast. Plenty of lift but more power is never too much. I can haul 4*5 bales wet/dry on a loader bale spear as if they where not there. I do have a BH on the rear most of the time, still using it a lot.
 
   / LS? #11  
That's definitely on the high end of what I'm thinking. $25K max spend is also what I'm thinking. While being able to handle heavy bales would be great I'm not sure that's the mainstream of what I'll be doing. I also need to finish mow 2-3ac and some of that is on a slope. I also like the smaller size to get into tight places. We'll see.

What do you consider a heavy bale? A tractor that weighs 2800lbs is going to have a hard time with a large round. If you arent moving them regularly long and uneven distances you might be fine with appropriate ballast. The problem with large rounds is how far they stick out and change center mass on a small machine.

Transmission on the MT240E is shuttle, not HST. Are you ready for that change?

Have you gotten any quotes yet?

In general LS should be a great machine, I would not hesitate to buy one if I had a reliable dealer in my area.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#12  
Thanks for all the info. Does the MT240 get the extra HP above the 235 by adding a turbo?

I'm just looking at simplicity. My theory is simple is better. Adding a turbo, another thing to fail, might not be worth 5 hp. It looks like the 230, 235, and 240 have the same engine displacement, so something is adding the 5 and 10 hp.

I'm planning for 20y/5000 hours.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#13  
What do you consider a heavy bale? A tractor that weighs 2800lbs is going to have a hard time with a large round. If you arent moving them regularly long and uneven distances you might be fine with appropriate ballast. The problem with large rounds is how far they stick out and change center mass on a small machine.

Transmission on the MT240E is shuttle, not HST. Are you ready for that change?

Have you gotten any quotes yet?

In general LS should be a great machine, I would not hesitate to buy one if I had a reliable dealer in my area.
Heavy bale. Good Q. 5' round is what I'm thinking but not a lot of moving. Lifting onto/off of a trailer and maybe 100 yards of travel.
I'm going with HST, so MT240HE or 235HE
$22.5K for the 40; $21K for the 35 is one quote I got.

That's about my limit. A 3 series might be good for some situations, but 70% of what I do is mow a lawn, brush hog in the woods with not a lot of turning radius, and grade my 1/2 mi driveway. The other is till a riding arena. The arena work might be better with a 3 series and some other implements, but not sure I can justify the cost. Open to ideas though.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#14  
Where does the HP come from?

I was looking at the specs. Most MT2 and MT3 use the same 114.7 cu in engine. Somehow they are going from 30 to 57 HP on the same displacement.
 
   / LS? #15  
Heavy bale. Good Q. 5' round is what I'm thinking but not a lot of moving. Lifting onto/off of a trailer and maybe 100 yards of travel.
I'm going with HST, so MT240HE or 235HE
$22.5K for the 40; $21K for the 35 is one quote I got.

That's about my limit. A 3 series might be good for some situations, but 70% of what I do is mow a lawn, brush hog in the woods with not a lot of turning radius, and grade my 1/2 mi driveway. The other is till a riding arena. The arena work might be better with a 3 series and some other implements, but not sure I can justify the cost. Open to ideas though.


See if they can demo loading and unloading a bale of that size from a trailer your height before you buy it. Just drop a bale on your trailer and take it to the dealership...let them do the rest.
 
   / LS? #16  
Thanks for all the info. Does the MT240 get the extra HP above the 235 by adding a turbo?

I'm just looking at simplicity. My theory is simple is better. Adding a turbo, another thing to fail, might not be worth 5 hp. It looks like the 230, 235, and 240 have the same engine displacement, so something is adding the 5 and 10 hp.

I'm planning for 20y/5000 hours.

PTO tasks? Might help the tiller and mowing.
 
   / LS? #17  
What do you consider a heavy bale? A tractor that weighs 2800lbs is going to have a hard time with a large round. If you arent moving them regularly long and uneven distances you might be fine with appropriate ballast. The problem with large rounds is how far they stick out and change center mass on a small machine.

Transmission on the MT240E is shuttle, not HST. Are you ready for that change?

Have you gotten any quotes yet?

In general LS should be a great machine, I would not hesitate to buy one if I had a reliable dealer in my area.
The MT240HE is Hydro.
 
   / LS? #18  
Heavy bale. Good Q. 5' round is what I'm thinking but not a lot of moving. Lifting onto/off of a trailer and maybe 100 yards of travel.
I'm going with HST, so MT240HE or 235HE
$22.5K for the 40; $21K for the 35 is one quote I got.

That's about my limit. A 3 series might be good for some situations, but 70% of what I do is mow a lawn, brush hog in the woods with not a lot of turning radius, and grade my 1/2 mi driveway. The other is till a riding arena. The arena work might be better with a 3 series and some other implements, but not sure I can justify the cost. Open to ideas though.
I think you can haggle and get the MT240HE for maybe 21.5-22K which is worth it to me.

I really think they should just drop the MT235 from the lineup.
 
   / LS? #19  
See if they can demo loading and unloading a bale of that size from a trailer your height before you buy it. Just drop a bale on your trailer and take it to the dealership...let them do the rest.
The MT240 will handle a bale up to about 1800-1900 no problem, I just wouldn't want to do it very often or for very far as the front axle/bearings aren't that big and it would sure wear them out faster than on an Mt3 or 4.
 
   / LS?
  • Thread Starter
#20  
The MT240 will handle a bale up to about 1800-1900 no problem, I just wouldn't want to do it very often or for very far as the front axle/bearings aren't that big and it would sure wear them out faster than on an Mt3 or 4.
Brings up a point. Are normal wearables like bearings a common part? Timken? National? SKF? etc or some proprietary part available only via dealer or manufacturer?
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2018 HYUNDAI VC2530152-JS DRY VAN TRAILER (A59575)
2018 HYUNDAI...
2023 BOBCAT E88 R2-SERIES EXCAVATOR (A60429)
2023 BOBCAT E88...
2013 Ford E-150 Passenger Van (A59230)
2013 Ford E-150...
Enclosed Service Truck (A55788)
Enclosed Service...
1977 Gleaner A630 Corn Head (A56436)
1977 Gleaner A630...
2023 Chevrolet Tahoe FL SUV (A59231)
2023 Chevrolet...
 
Top