Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help...

   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help...
  • Thread Starter
#21  
All,

Thanks again. I'll respond with what I can below and will TRY to keep it to a minimum...I went to the Kubota dealer yesterday, but didn't make it before they'd closed. At least I got to look at several of the tractors, including an L3710 and an M4900 with cab.

cowboydoc, you've got the right idea here, in that I'm trying to capture a much as possible with 1 machine, rather than trying to afford several machines to do it all. I definitely can't afford a Cat III-sized tractor, so hopefully Cat II is sufficient. It sounds to me like the Grand L Series is a no-go on pulling a 15' mower, am I gathering that correctly from your info? (Remember - I'm pretty "green" to all of this!). If my application dictates that I *need* the larger sized tractor, I will forego HST, no problem. Is the PTO HP the limiter as far as the size mower you can pull? I may have to contact Rhino on this one and ask specifically about their wing and see what pops out. I'm still looking for "exactly" what implements can run on Cat II but not Cat I, and still wondering if it's just a matter of the "Size" of the implement.

Bird, it looks like I'm heading towards the bigger tractors now, so thanks for the words of encouragement. I drive stick-shift automobiles, so I"m used to clutching to change speeds/etc, just it's a lot more "heavy-duty" on a tractor. I'll definitely look into the powershift transmission.

glennmac, sorry if I didn't make clear what our intentions are with the property. It's probably because we're not really sure ourselves just yet. Disclaimer: what I say below is all subject to change, because I have no idea what I'm talking about. The 15 acres of woods we're planning on managing somewhat. It was logged 2 years ago and there are many piles of discarded lumber that will need to be removed for mulch/firewood. The tractor path through this small forest has totally grown over and many of the lumber piles are on it, so we'll need to clear this. Going forward we'll probably maintain this for firewood and the natural stand of hardwood trees contained in it, as well as keeping the path through the 15 acres clear of brush. The 15 acres of pasture will need to be mowed short-term and this is where we plan to begin our experimentation with tree farming. It should give us plenty of room to play with row spacings and let us figure out how long it takes certain trees to grow, how to care for them, etc... You are correct, we'll be renting out the other 60 acres to "traditional" vegetable farmers for now. Once we get a better handle on what we're doing and, if we still want to push forward with the tree farming nursery, the rentals will stop and we'll expand our plantings to the other 60 acres. Now, just LOOKING at this land we have, that seems like WAY too much land for my wife and myself to manage in a nursery operation, so we'll map out areas we use for tree farming (miuch of this may depend on soil samples to be done down the road) and the rest we'll start to grow up with "our own" trees, so the property will eventually become a nursery surrounded by its own trees. Here, we'll most likely begin by spading trees from our original 15-acre nursery experiment and plopping them all over the property where we want the forest to be. Of course, if this experiment doesn't work out, I'll either need to continue mowing/hauling lumber on the 15 + 15 acres or may try "traditional" vegetable farming beginning with a 20 acre field and progressing through the others. I wish I had a concrete plan, but I don't, so this is where we're currently heading.

cowboydoc, thanks for the reminder from my original post. The tractor will also need to do our plowing/tilling/dirt moving operations. There's a pretty big laneway down the property which I'm not sure should be plowed during the winter (I guess this will depend on whether I need to reach the back of the property or not!). Sounds like you're still leaning me to the bigger tractor! :) Thanks for the input, I'm attaching an aerial photo from New York State from a while back of the land so you can see the layout. I'll include a "doctored" version as well, hopefully this will make some things more "clear".

Von, I didn't get to talk to the dealer I went to yesterday (Saxby), but I'm making a note to look into Art White in Syracuse. I'm guessing I'll most likely go with Carver now, but if a local dealer can match him, they'll probably get my business. Thanks for the info.

John Miller III, Wow, that's pushing me even further to the realm of even bigger tractors. However, if the price is on par, I'll look into it. It seems that the tractors are priced $1,000 - $2,000 apart with identical features and just going up to the next size. This seems to apply to the L3710 - L4310 - L4610 - M4900 - M5700 - M6800, and may continue further. The jump from L3710 to M6800 looks to be ~$7,500. If only we weren't so strapped for cash from actually PURCHASING this place, I might be more easy to convince to jump up. I will bring this one up with the Mrs. :)

glennmac, I'm trying to do the research on what we'll need for tree farming before I buy anything...my research tells me I'll eventually need BOTH a tractor and skid steer, my finances tell me to stick with the tractor for now. It can do the "tree" things a skid steer can, just not as fast and fun as one. We're looking to grow the following: Sequoia Sempervirens, Sequoiadendron Giganteum, Metasequoia Glyptostroboides, Taxodium Distichum, Picea Pungens 'Glauca', Picea Abies, Pinus Nigra, Gingko Biloba, Quercus Alba, Quercus Rubra, Acer Saccarum, Acer Rubrum, Larix Laricina, Abies Concolor, Juglans Regia, Ulmus Americana and Castanea Dentata to start. Translated, that's Coast redwood, Giant Sequoia, Dawn Redwood, Bald-Cypress, Colorado Blue Spruce, Norway Spruce, Austrian Pine, Ginkgo Biloba, White Oak, Red Oak, Sugar Maple, Red Maple, Tamarack, White Fir, English Walnut, American Elm and American Chestnut. The elm and chestnut are "pet" projects aimed to help bring these trees back from the brink of extinction in the Eastern US.

Sorry so wordy...thanks for all help!
 

Attachments

  • 1-76838-LandPlans.jpg
    1-76838-LandPlans.jpg
    186.1 KB · Views: 125
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #22  
Also from a Rochester suburb.
From a snow removal point of wiew, a rear mount snow blower would be my choice. Remember, that with a cab, you will need a remote to control the chute direction.
I have also been looking into a larger piece of land and have been casually looking into something larger than what I currently have. For the minor difference in price, I would opt for the M6800 over the M4900 M5700. From my research, the grand L will not be able to handle a decent size rotary cutter; whereas it would not be a problem for the M6800. M6800 also comes with extendable lower links which would certainly be an asset when hooking up some of those larger implements. The last time I checked Carver's site, the L4610 and the M4900 were similarly priced at about $31,000. And the M5700 and M6800 were both priced at $33,000. All of these with loader and cab (it is a nice cab). After this last summer...with the high heat and humidity...I wish that I had a cab. Unfortunately, in addition to the upgrade cost, the list price for a grand L cab (loaded) is about $7,500.
Good luck, Tom
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #23  
After reading your last post go out and buy the largest M-series you can afford. Just make sure to get a front end loader as well. Then down the road you can get a smaller tractor as needed.

Got one question about the trees your going to plant. Are they all going to grow ok in your area? Might want to talk with the local forester or extension service before buying a bunch of seedlings and then having them die the first hard winter. /w3tcompact/icons/frown.gif

Here is a link to some really good tree calculators. http://www.timberbuyer.net/toolbox.shtml

A really good forum to get questions about trees answered. http://www.forestryforum.com/cgi-bin/board/YaBB.pl

Five best places to buy trees off the net. <A HREF="http://forestry.about.com/library/weekly/aatp102201.htm
" target="_new">http://forestry.about.com/library/weekly/aatp102201.htm
</A>

good luck
Gordon

8-41268-jgforestrytractor.jpg
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #24  
<font color=blue>I'm still looking for "exactly" what implements can run on Cat II but not Cat I, and still wondering if it's just a matter of the "Size" of the implement</font color=blue>

Mike, you know the pins are larger on Cat II tractors and implements, and the pins on the lower link maybe farther apart, because the lower links on a Cat II tractor are bigger and will spread farther apart. Now as for which Cat II implements cannot be used on Cat I; probably none of them without changing the linkage pins at least, and then they may be too heavy for a Cat I tractor. But basically, you're right that Cat II implements are just bigger, heavier, and do the work faster. Generally speaking, you can use Cat I implements on a Cat II tractor by either using bushings on the pins, or in many cases Cat II tractors have ball joints in the lower links that have both Cat I and II holes, but you can't use Cat II implements on a Cat I tractor. As far as "exactly" which implements . . ., well, I don't know. It really is for the most part a matter of size.

Bird
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #25  
Mike,
There are two things that are going to limit you with implements primarily: 1. hp and 2. hydraulics. The last limiter is going to be weight. You need all three to run the higher end implements, esp. a tree spade or like a 15' batwing. Those same things will limit you from using cat. II impl. on a cat. I tractor. After reading this post I really think you will only be happy with a utility tractor and not a compact.

18-35034-TRACTO~1.GIF
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #26  
We have only one overstock L4610 hst unit with loader and cab @ $28350. -http://carverequipment.com/cool_season_new.htm
Thanks,
Steve
 

Attachments

  • 1-76957-L4610hst-Cabw-Loader.jpg
    1-76957-L4610hst-Cabw-Loader.jpg
    85.1 KB · Views: 132
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #27  
Mike: The 6800 is now available with hydro-shuttle, which allows clutchless shifting from forward to stop to reverse and back. I went through the same sorting out you did, and wound up with the 6800 for the reasons many of the others on this thread laid out for you. Don't know why Kubota's site doesn't reflect that option, which can give us the best of both worlds. The pricing increments are small for what you get in return. Regarding the loader, the self-levelling loader with detachable bucket gives a max. of flexibility for the future.
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #28  
mikeslavis
Made a trip to my dealers today, took the camera, pretty sure he had tree transplanter on the lot. The attached pics show a reconditioned mod. 500 3P mounted on a L4300DT. It is cat 1. Holes in attachment will allow cat2 pins. They stated they sell quite a few for the L series and the people love them. I learned a lot about tree transplanters today/w3tcompact/icons/wink.gif. Apparently a 20" ball mach. is for a 2" trunk dia. 30" ball for 3" trunk etc.
He mentioned one customeer using the 20" on a L3010, guy then upgrades to a L4610, then upgrades to the 30" transplanter. Dealer says they love it. The website for this transplanter is www.caretree.com.
If you don't find what you need there, I have about 20 pics and some brochures. Hope this helps.
regards
Mutt
 

Attachments

  • 1-77099-Dsc00037.jpg
    1-77099-Dsc00037.jpg
    84.5 KB · Views: 132
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #29  
pic 2
 

Attachments

  • 1-77102-Dsc00027.jpg
    1-77102-Dsc00027.jpg
    94.4 KB · Views: 123
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #30  
pic 3
Note: this set-up requires one pair of hyd. remotes
 

Attachments

  • 1-77103-Dsc00034.jpg
    1-77103-Dsc00034.jpg
    90.6 KB · Views: 143
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help...
  • Thread Starter
#31  
Tom/WNY, Thanks for the info. At this point it looks like I'm ordering a tractor, and I did get three remotes for it, so hopefully I'll be OK once I've added a loader and possibly rear-mounted snow thrower. I also can add a fourth remote later, if need be. I'm a big believer in getting the most of everything you can because you never know what you're going to need (especially if you're as ignorant as I am about tractors - but I'm getting there).

gordon, I listened to your advice, and bought the largest tractor I could afford. However, it didn't leave me with any $$$ for the FEL. My wife and I figure we'll manually shovel the drive this year and then, in spring after our tax rebate, we'll look into getting the FEL. On the trees - there are only 2 that I'm worried about not making it in our Zone 5/6 climate here in Rochester, Coast Redwood and Giant Sequoia. The others should be able to make it. We've bought a couple of seedlings of both Coast Redwood and Giant Sequoia, which are container potted right now. We're going to keep them that way for another year or so and then plant them when they're larger. If they make it, we'll know enough to give it a shot. For us, this is a big experiment and we wanted to have some fun with it. Most of our investment will be in NY native trees, but we wanted to throw some fun ones in there as well, just to see. Thanks for the links. I've also been looking at:


http://www.dec.state.ny.us/website/dlf/privland/nursery/species.html

http://itascagreenhouse.com/page3.html

and, for seeds:
http://www.treeshrubseeds.com/
http://carterseeds.com/

Bird, Thanks, that's what I thought, I just wanted to make sure.

cowboydoc, Thanks again, I went with a good size utility tractor. I figure if we can't afford additonal machinery in the future, a bigger tractor can do most of the things the specialty equipment could. A Bobcat may be much better for spading trees, but a good size tractor can still do it.

Steve_Carver, your site has been very helpful in figuring out a lot of what's-what with the Kubotas. I think there's more information there than on kubota.com!

winejon, Kubota's site doesn't really list a WHOLE lot of the finer details of the machines. Also, I think that the hydro-shuttle was added to the M6800 recently, and I don't think they bothered to update the web site. This is a feature which, indeed, would have pushed me to the M6800.

HR_Mutt, awesome pics. Thanks a lot for them, it's nice to know that decent-size spades can be run off of these tractors. I have looked into caretree and they are a possibility once I've got the trees and the $$$ to get a spade. I am also looking into Optimal since they seem to make more compact spades, which still dig up the same size trees as the caretree spades. See http://www.optimaltreespades.com/optimal-advantage.html for details. The smaller spade would make maneuvering around trees in rows much easier, I think. At any rate, I'm too early in researching tree spades to know all the in/outs, but that's what I know so far!

All you guys, it's been real interesting seeing what you all thought about my situation and (I can't say it enough) thanks again for bearing with me on my long posts. I originally started by looking at Case, John Deere, Massey-Ferguson, New Holland and Kubota, but when I saw that Kubota was the only manufacturer with a cab on the compact-size tractors, I figured I'd see if I could manage with an L3710HSTC (since we definitely knew we wanted a cab). Of course, this "grew" to an M4700, which "grew" to an M6800. At this point I went back and looked at the other manufacturers as well, and wound up signing paperwork for a New Holland TN75S with cab last night. Please don't hate me because I went blue! The New Holland dealer here (Jennings Tractor) is amazing - by FAR the best of the dealers I went to, and the Kubota dealer (Saxby) didn't seem to take me very seriously, didn't even have an M6800 on the lot (although they told me they did when I called on the phone) and gave me the impression that the Kubotas were selling like hotcakes (maybe they are) and I felt like he'd be reluctant to deal with me very much (or in the least, it would be like pulling teeth - and I hate haggling). Carver offers a great option with his web site, but I prefer dealing with someone local and I didn't know how the Kubota from Carver would have shaped up with the options I wanted (price-wise and time-wise). New Holland also has 0.0%/3 years - 1.9%/4 years and 2.9%/5 years financing right now, which pushed me over the edge. Again, THANK YOU so much. Even though I didn't go Kubota, I hope you'll all be happy knowing that I got enough tractor for my purposes, and that you helped me make the decision (so I didn't wind up with too "little" tractor).

Mike Slavis
mike@slavis.com
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #32  
Congratulations, Mike, I feel sure you'll be happy with that tractor, except for one little detail. Have you checked on the price of the FEL as part of the original purchase as compared with the price to add it later? You usually get a better deal if it's part of the original purchase. In my opinion a FEL is essential and with the financing options available, I would think you would be ahead of the game to get it originally. And of course, that's just my personal opinion.

Bird
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #33  
hdr_tn_tractors.gif

tn75.gif


Mike,

New Holland TN75…Outstanding hydraulics, great PTO hp, turbo charged DI… more than what Kubota M6800 could ever offer you…

You made a fantastic choice….!

Congratulations Mike… your great grandkids will love ya for it… /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif

18-35196-JDMFWDSigJFM.JPG
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #34  
Mike,

I agree with Bird... I missed that part on you not getting the loader...

Getting it now, only adds a few more dollars on the payment, makes your dealer happy{probably even a better price now also}, and you and the Mrs. will be happier...

{Besides...it's kinda like ordering the brand new car without air conditioning and saying you'll come back for the retro-fit later...Sometimes... later never comes...}

18-35196-JDMFWDSigJFM.JPG
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #35  
Mike,

Congrats! That will make a fine tractor for many years to come. Don't worry about going blue, you are still allowed to visit with us orange guys and gals. Glad to see you moved up to a tractor that will handle anything you want to do on your land.

MarkV
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #36  
Mike
The pic John provided looks like a great rig/w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif.What's the engine/pto hp? I wouldn't think you'll offend anybody by going <font color=blue>Blue</font color=blue>.You're the one paying for it/keeping us advised on how the projects go,etc(with pics!)
regards
Mutt
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help...
  • Thread Starter
#37  
Bird and John Miller, III, This tractor is already over what we had designated as our budget, so adding the FEL from the get-go is probably not going to happen. Taking on $4,500 for the 33LA FEL, our monthly payments (if we go with the 3 year, 0.0% financing) will go up $125, which is pretty significant. I'm still hoping that come tax refund time, there will be enough to look into adding the FEL then. I'm not looking forward to manually shoveling snow this winter, but it's not gonna kill me (and I can still get this much tractor!). Also, my dealer, who's been nothing but straight with me, told me it will not save me money to get it now as he'll give me a great price either way. He also said that on the compact tractors, the New Holland "Boomers", there is a factory rebate applied if there are accessories purchased (like a FEL) with the tractor, but this doesn't apply to the larger TN tractors.

HR_Mutt, here are the relevant specs:

Engine: 3-cyl turbo diesel
74.8 Gross Engine HP
72 Net engine HP
62 PTO HP

Transmission: 16x16 synchronized transmission with electro-hydraulic powershuttle
Differential lock electrohydraulically engaged front and rear

Steering/Braking: Hydrostatic power steering with separate hydraulic pump
Hydraulic wet brakes (equalizing and self-adjusting)
SuperSteer FWD axle with automatic FWD management system

Hydraulics: Dual gear pumps
Implement pump: 16.9 gpm
Steering pump: 9.2 gpm

PTO: 11 inch cerametallic PTO clutch
Mechanical engagement

3-point lift: 2-lever control (position/draft)
3962 lbs. lift capacity
Cat II/I
Telescopic stabilizers
Flexible lower link ends
Lower link draft sensing

Gauges: Electronic instrument cluster with digital readouts

Electrical/lighting: 65 amp alternator
7-pin outlet for trailer lighting
4-pin 25 AMP power outler
Single pin 8 AMP accessory power outler (cigarette lighter)
2 Halogen fron headlights
2 halogen front corner worklights
2 Front cab roof worklights
2 Read cab roof worklights
Turn signals/flashers/brake lights

Inside: Heat and A/C
Isolation mounted platform
Locking doors
Tinted glass
Fully opening rear window
Fron and rear wipers/washers
Tilt/Telescoping steering wheel
Radio ready
Seat belts

I'm really excited about this, and just hope I can handle it in the beginning!

Mike Slavis
mike@slavis.com
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #38  
Mike, I do understand about budget limitations./w3tcompact/icons/frown.gif At any rate, that sounds like a fine machine.

Bird
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #39  
Re: Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help..

Mike,
Thats a great tractor, and Jennings has a good following around here. My next door neighbor just got a TC33D from them about 2 months ago, had the samething to say about them and the other dealers as well.

And since you and I are so close to one an other, I will be glad to come and drive your tractor for you and show you how it looks moving around! Best of luck with your new toy!

18-30445-von.gif
 
   / Purchase Grand L Ten or M Series? Need help... #40  
<font color=blue>...I'm not looking forward to manually shoveling snow this winter, but it's not gonna kill me (and I can still get this much tractor!). ...</font color=blue>

Mike, You sure did get a lot of tractor... that was a pleasant surprise!

Ok, get the loader come tax time... but how about a 3-pt rear blade for now, even used for snow plowing... /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif

{wider and quicker than a shovel...couple hundred $$.../w3tcompact/icons/wink.gif}

18-35196-JDMFWDSigJFM.JPG
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

Kubota HB84 Hopper Broom (A53317)
Kubota HB84 Hopper...
Unused 2025 CFG Industrial XZ20R Mini Excavator (A59228)
Unused 2025 CFG...
2017 Kubota M7-151 Premium MFWD Tractor (A56438)
2017 Kubota M7-151...
PumpJack Brand Pump Jack (A56438)
PumpJack Brand...
2022 Chevrolet 1500 Silverado Crew Cab 4X4 Pick-Up Truck (A59230)
2022 Chevrolet...
UNKNOWN  500BBL FRAC TANK (A58214)
UNKNOWN 500BBL...
 
Top