Thats why i posted it, from what i got here even from Gary who tore his down, it sounded like it was solid metal?
But yea, when i opened the new one yesterday, i was thingking "huh new design", as the one on there looked like solid metal. But it too had a rubber backing. Which makes sense how it seals to the axle so well i guess.
The new carrier and seal fit nice n snugly on the new collar, it should not leak!
I remember about the screw drivers thats kind of where the idea came from that and common sense. But i could not tap screw drivers in behind the seal as it was seized to the axle and nothing would go back there and pry. I was worried about maring and jarring the bearings why i did not do to much of it. Thats where the chisel worked it loosend the rubbers grip and i was able to slip it out a 1/16 or so then slip the screw drivers back there and pry.
And yes you would have to take the axle off to press that bearing out. I was not going to do that so i did not want to remove the axle.