Not having the benefit of all this wisdom, we sort of went with our best judgment at the time and fortunately it worked out. We paid for college with savings and by borrowing. We borrowed some and the two daughters borrowed some. We were OK with this as both had very good grades and were responsible. While in college each - on their own - found jobs - both had several different jobs - some overlapping. There was never a time they were in school that they did not work, including the Summers.
Once they were out of school, they paid their loans, we paid the parent loans. Each one at different times received one of our old subcompact cars - each about 6 years old at the time - which we were phasing out. We explained that we would pay their car insurance and cell phone bills for the first six months, and that they were responsible to maintain the cars. They kept those cars for a very long time - one was sold with 230,000 or so miles on it, and the other one still has hers with about 190,000 miles.
After they were out of college we "seeded" a Vanguard stock account with $500 and told them we would match up to $500 a year for three years if they added to that account. They were not particularly excited or interested. . . until they began to receive quarterly statements showing that those accounts had more than $500 in them. They then started adding money and continue to do so. Each of those $500 seeded accounts now holds about $40,000 plus. And only about $1,000 of that for each was money we provided.
They always knew what to expect, what we would do for them and what they had to do for themselves. It has all worked out. It may not have been the optimum way to manage things but we were very glad to be able to help. When we are helping them out I always think about how there are many kids who have no one, no support, no one to look to when they need to, and, well, that makes me glad that we are there for them. I recognize of course, that those who have no one can equally succeed, learn great lessons on their own and so on, but that will not always be the case.
Both are now married, working, saving, one has a great home, another is looking to buy, and they need nothing from us and ask for nothing. And we have grand kids. I know that a lot of this outcome is luck, but sometimes luck needs a hand too.