Richard, if your "45%" setting is actually 45% of 250 amps, you're about 25% too LOW on amps - have you "calibrated" your wire speed settings to know what IPM you're ACTUALLY running?
Wuz gonna post a link, but it looks like Jody's video on "calibration" isn't available - basically pick a knob setting, pull the trigger for 6 seconds, measure the length of wire (not actually welding of course), multiply by 10, write it down, change setting, repeat til you have a CHART... otherwise you're more or less just flying blind.
That weld looks like it's just laying on TOP of the steel to me - if it were mine, I'd turn up the heat and concentrate on PUSH angle, short stickout and staying at the FRONT of the puddle - admittedly, if Carl has only been welding a few weeks then I've been at it (MIG anyway) for SECONDS (about 5 years real time) -
But, thanks (in part) to Jody @ weldingtipsand tricks, so far nothing I've built has broke (my "break test" is build it, abuse it, fix whatever broke and/or add bracing

...Steve