I have had several different ones over the years. I would never buy another soft one, but some I had were O.K. They just don't last long term in my opinion. I had a Bak Flip, and like it, but it seemed like it might not hold up well over the long haul. I sold the truck when it was about 3 years old so I wasn't sure about the long run. I had a little bit of problems with the weatherstip on it and wasn't sure about how well the rubber that held the sections together would hold up. What was really nice about the Bak Flip, it folded up against the rear window of the truck, so it was 100% out of the way of the bed if you wanted it to be. I also had the kind the wind up into a box in the front of the bed. Its still a hard cover, but gets out of the way in about 2 seconds. This was probably my favorite style. The only draw back is that they can frezze and not open up. This was never a problem for me as I kept in inside, but I've heard other people complain about it.