I, for one, wonder how folks as irresponsible and seemingly dishonest as this neighbor's daughter can continue to get drivers' licenses. I am in health care and am compassionate about most things, but there comes a point where no matter what one's disabilities might be, he/she must undertake some responsibility for actions taken. If the account of events is correct, can there be any doubt she hit the dog and then fled the scene? A 145 pound dog would be like hitting a person and if she cannot determine whether she hit that or not, she need not be driving. It is just a matter of time and circumstance before something else happens. Either way she has some explaining to do. If she does not truly know, she needs a driving competency test. If she does she exhibits insight to the point of lying to avoid repercussions. It sounds as though her parents are trying to protect her, which is fine, but I would not be done with this matter until evidence is seen. Although I know it is a loss, the thing that really burns me is the denial. We all, me especially, make mistakes. Bad things happen, but when someone is dishonest about his/her involvement, that person, no matter who they are needs at least some accountability. To me, such actions are pretty low on the list of human behaviors.
John M