California
Super Star Member
- Joined
- Jan 22, 2004
- Messages
- 14,680
- Location
- An hour north of San Francisco
- Tractor
- Yanmar YM240 Yanmar YM186D
What are you making there?
What are you making there?
What are you making there?
I guess the biggest trouble with keeping a stick welder that gets used only once per decade is having fresh rod on-hand when the occasion arrives to need it. That stuff doesn't stay fresh forever, no matter how you try to store it out of the elements, unless your shop happens to be in Arizona.Thats why I got a wire welder. I welded stick in the field service and manufacturing for 20+ years. Now I avoid it like the plague.
Questions from a amateur:Thats why I got a wire welder. I welded stick in the field service and manufacturing for 20+ years. Now I avoid it like the plague.
Some will say "yes" some will say "no".... A lot depends on the mods of the HF unit.... Personally I sold my Lincoln 180 amp "tombstone " and later replaced it with Hobart Handler 140 MIG and so far it has done all the things I require of it for up to 1/4 inch materials in single pass... Anything big triple pass.... With MIG its more about work prep then anything else....Questions from a amateur:
I have a '60's MW PowrKraft 230 AC stick welder. As big as a Lincoln tombstone. And a big box of 6011 that must be 30 years old. So far as I can see still usable. I've welded a couple of heavy things, for example a hitch ball mount onto the back of my box blade. The original arc torch is fun to play with but I've never used it for anything. Maybe it's hot enough to bend metal?
Then I got a used HF MIG-180 that some experimenter had modified up to the specs (not quality!) of a real welder. Big capacitor, all cables heavier gauge, start delay for the gas, longer whip. For $25, I just couldn't pass it up.
Would the HF realistically take the place of the ancient 100 lb stick welder?
I still have and occasionally use my 1979 Sears Craftsman AC/DC arc welder. Very occasionally. I also bought a Hobart Handler 140 about a decade or more ago. It gets used the most. But for thick stuff, I like the arc welder. Since the arc welder can sit for 5-10 years between uses, to get around ancient welding rod, I buy the smallest box possible. It's still less than $15 for a 5lb box of 6011 at most big box stores locally, so I just buy a new box if I think I need to.Some will say "yes" some will say "no".... A lot depends on the mods of the HF unit.... Personally I sold my Lincoln 180 amp "tombstone " and later replaced it with Hobart Handler 140 MIG and so far it has done all the things I require of it for up to 1/4 inch materials in single pass... Anything big triple pass.... With MIG its more about work prep then anything else....
Make a test weld with each welder. Cut the welds apart and see what they actually look like.Questions from a amateur:
I have a '60's MW PowrKraft 230 AC stick welder. As big as a Lincoln tombstone. And a big box of 6011 that must be 30 years old. So far as I can see still usable. I've welded a couple of heavy things, for example a hitch ball mount onto the back of my box blade. The original arc torch is fun to play with but I've never used it for anything. Maybe it's hot enough to bend metal?
Then I got a used HF MIG-180 that some experimenter had modified up to the specs (not quality!) of a real welder. Big capacitor, all cables heavier gauge, start delay for the gas, longer whip. For $25, I just couldn't pass it up.
Would the HF realistically take the place of the ancient 100 lb stick welder?