I used to go through a sequence of cranking with compression released, then TS for 10-15 seconds, then crank with compression released (briefly) and then unreleased (after a rotation or two). My 1510 would start after multiple iterations of this sequence, but it wasn't quick by any means and it seemed like a lot of stress on the starter.
This fall I read a post from Scotty Dive and he said it worked much better if he held the TS on his for more like 45-60 seconds.
Holding the TS longer is like a night and day difference. We've had what I would call a cold winter here in central MA. I've had to go out and clear snow in 10 degree weather which has never happened before (8th winter with the 1510 this year). The tractor sits in the bottom floor of a barn with plenty of ventilation, so it can't be more than about 15 degrees in there. I still go through the same starting sequence, but I only do it once (twice when it was only 10 outside) and don't crank with compression engaged for more than a few seconds total. The thing starts right up. As soon as you release the decompression lever, you can hear the engine starting to fire.
So I'd just hold the TS for longer. My parents live near you, and I can't imagine a cold spell in SW Ohio where you'd need a heater of any kind to get a YM started with a thermostart.