I prefer a good Italian made hiking boot for the good ankle support and high arch. I went to NOLS after highschool for a 4 week backpack trip. It was mandatory to either get Scarpa's or LaSportiva boots and spend a couple of months breaking them in. I went with the Scarpa's and they were fantastic. I have also purchased some LaSportiva and danners since. The danners are now sitting in a closet needing a resole while the much older Scarpa and LaSportiva boots are still in great shape.
I don't like goretex in a boot. It gets too hot. I prefer an all leather boot with a leather lining. A person can keep it waterproof with good conditioners. It will last for decades.
Probably the best leather boot ever made. These are around 25 years old.