40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice

   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice
  • Thread Starter
#61  
rSckotty, appreciate your point of view. Will look into what I can afford to buy used w/cash until I get the hang of the property and what I'm after. I think I'll start with looking around at local dealers.

I am very much of the" buy once, cry once" philosophy. If I can find a good enough price on used, I may be comfortable with a second, future purchase.

LouNY: Figured I would see how the first winter went as to sanding and haven't given it much thought, so thanks for mentioning it. The road is shaded and the snow surely won't melt. Will keep this in mind. BTW, I grew up in VT and have looked at moving back that way in the past, but tough to find good work where I grew up these days.

Started looking at Power Trac again after getting scared off by no dealer network. Having trouble seeing a downside, other than do dealers, to the 2460. Looks like a great value w/ low center of gravity. Not a ton of info on that model in the PT forum. Thoughts on the PT-2460?
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #62  
Started looking at Power Trac again after getting scared off by no dealer network. Having trouble seeing a downside, other than do dealers, to the 2460. Looks like a great value w/ low center of gravity. Not a ton of info on that model in the PT forum. Thoughts on the PT-2460?

I don't know the Power Trac so cannot comment on them.
On the scale of important things I'd be sure to get power steering and hopefully a wide, adjustable wheel base.
Consider that one of the few things that all tractors and manufacturers agree on is the usefulness of the 3 pt hitch. In fact, go with a category II 3pt if you can. Cat II hitches can use cat I implements but not vice versa.
Check for accessible & independent PTO operation.
Tractors push OK, but they pull even better. Plan on pulling a blade downhill a lot.

I've found several nice tractors by looking at the advertisements in small town rural newspapers & Ag journals...
rScotty
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #63  
Pugemasta,
I would be quite careful of those grades in this part of the country. I have a 1/2 mile driveway that was gravel and is now paved the high moisture snows and cold rains we can get can produce some remarkably slick conditions. My wife and i have have both taken long scary rides on the 13 percent sections of our drive when it was dirt even with 4wd and really good studded snows. We had a small loop drive that was about 15-20 and i remember a slide down it with a fully chained kubota b3030 in 4wd with blower and blade down trying to limit the speed i was picking up. I turned that section back into grass.


I would do whatever you can to make those grades as gradual as possible, even if you and your family can make it up (and down safely) your friends, contractors ,delivery people probably can't, which becomes a pain especially if they block you in or out.

What ever you get you will need aggressive chains on all 4 corners. You will need a rear blade for maintenance anyway so you might as well use it for snow clearing for a while and see what its limitations are. Bigger and beefier is better both for grading your road and for trying to scrape the ice down. The folks above who indicated that you will plow down and drive up are most probably correct.

Blowers:
For a mile drive with a blower a rear push is not really a good option. I could not imagine backing that far.
A front blower would be fine but the only setup that makes sense there to me is a mid pto. Both a driveline from the rear Pto and a hydraulic power pack in the rear seem inefficient to me though some swear by them (see GRS the great on TBN who is across the line in ID). A rear pull could work but with any blower you will need to blade the drive till it is frozen solid.

You asked a couple of times if anyone had a rear pull and I do and like it a lot. Very simple to use. Just drive forward and it just kinda follows you. I find it very easy to use and prefer it over the front setup had before. For a mile i would want a Good size utility tractor with as much pto hp as possible. the larger machine will let you drive through deeper drifts and enable a higher travel speed. A wider swath, say 96 inches would let you do a down and back and call it done, you don't really want extra trips. Right now the consensus seems to be that the Normands are the most durable but there are a few good options, almost all of them from Canada. With enough HP you should be able to blow at a pretty good clip- I can do 6-7 mph down hill 5-6 uphill in a 6 inch snow.

Feel free to ask any other rear pull Q's you might have. Probably the best information resource on those is found on Plowsite in the heavy equipment section


rSckotty, appreciate your point of view. Will look into what I can afford to buy used w/cash until I get the hang of the property and what I'm after. I think I'll start with looking around at local dealers.

I am very much of the" buy once, cry once" philosophy. If I can find a good enough price on used, I may be comfortable with a second, future purchase.

LouNY: Figured I would see how the first winter went as to sanding and haven't given it much thought, so thanks for mentioning it. The road is shaded and the snow surely won't melt. Will keep this in mind. BTW, I grew up in VT and have looked at moving back that way in the past, but tough to find good work where I grew up these days.

Started looking at Power Trac again after getting scared off by no dealer network. Having trouble seeing a downside, other than do dealers, to the 2460. Looks like a great value w/ low center of gravity. Not a ton of info on that model in the PT forum. Thoughts on the PT-2460?
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #64  
rSckotty, appreciate your point of view. Will look into what I can afford to buy used w/cash until I get the hang of the property and what I'm after. I think I'll start with looking around at local dealers.

I am very much of the" buy once, cry once" philosophy. If I can find a good enough price on used, I may be comfortable with a second, future purchase.

LouNY: Figured I would see how the first winter went as to sanding and haven't given it much thought, so thanks for mentioning it. The road is shaded and the snow surely won't melt. Will keep this in mind. BTW, I grew up in VT and have looked at moving back that way in the past, but tough to find good work where I grew up these days.

Started looking at Power Trac again after getting scared off by no dealer network. Having trouble seeing a downside, other than do dealers, to the 2460. Looks like a great value w/ low center of gravity. Not a ton of info on that model in the PT forum. Thoughts on the PT-2460?

I would look at the slope rating on that 2460. It sits pretty high. Call Terry at the factory and ask some questions about it. 1-800-the-yard.
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #66  
Iowa Farm Equipment is an Antonio Carraro dealer. I have purchased implements from IFE several times and in my experience IFE is ready to ship immediately.
LINK: Iowa Farm Equipment

We frequently read vehement complaints about the cost and complexity of Tier IV emission technology, particularly the DPF component. We also read comments on the expense of tractor service and how imprecise some dealer mechanics are. Tier IV and DPF is nothing, NOTHING compared to the cost and complexity of an AC. :)

I like simple.


Power Trac is an advanced tractor design with many of AC's attributes. Power Trac is manufactured in Tazewell, Virginia with mostly USA components. Power Trac has about as many viable, single brand dealers as Antonio Carraro, which is ONE (+/-). Power Trac is competitively priced. As Power Trac is an iteration of mining equipment, Power Trac is not as pretty as Antonio Carraro. I SPECULATE the quantity of Power Trac tractors sold in the USA is multiples of the volume enjoyed by Antonio Carraro. :)
LINK: Power Trac

Both brands have avid supporters. Neither brand is burning up the tractor market.

I admire Antonio Carraro. I admire Power Trac. I own Kubota.

You can't compare Antonio Carrara to Power Trac. They are apples and oranges.

- AC's have 3pt hitches. PT's don't.
- AC's have PTO shafts. PT's have hydraulically powered implements.
- AC's have about 15 dealers in the U.S.
Antonio Carraro US (MGH Equipment LLC) - North American Distributor for Antonio Carraro Tractors and Parts
- PT has no dealers and is factory direct only.
- All implements on a PT are out in front on the FEL arms.
- The FEL is integral to the PT and comes standard on ALL models.
- An FEL on an AC is a rare beast. Good luck finding one.
- You can get cab model AC's. No such option on PT.
- PT is NOT a tractor. It won't pull a dirt plow very well at all.
- AC IS a tractor.
- PT has no range selector. No Low range. No High range. Just a very good for what it does range.
- AC's are available with several options for ranges.
- ALL PT's are hydraulically driven.
- AC has HST and GEAR options.
- ALL PT's are steered by hydraulic articulation.
- SOME AC's are articulated. SOME AC's are steered with the front wheels.
- PT's come standard with a quick attach system.
- AC's do not.

While PT is made in Tazewell, VA, they use Deutz diesel engines, Kohler and Robin gas engines, European pumps and valves and connectors, and I believe they make their own hydraulic cylinders.

There's more.... but I'm tired. ;)

I cannot find accurate pricing for AC.
PT posts their prices on their website.

And finally, any weekday (with the possible exception of during hunting season), you can call PT and speak directly to the people that make it. They know every iteration of their products and are more than willing to help with repair suggestions if needed. Parts are 2 days away by UPS.

AC?

 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice
  • Thread Starter
#67  
It's too bad ACs don't work well with FELs. Hydrostatics are also few and far between I'm finding.

Thanks mossroad. Remembering another reason I dismissed Power Trac early on, I couldn't picture it being as effective at road maintenance pushing the impliments. As gathered from another thread, at least the 425 sounds inferior to a traditional tractor in using a box blade. Any owners of larger PTs use them for road maintenance?
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #68  
It's too bad ACs don't work well with FELs. Hydrostatics are also few and far between I'm finding.

Thanks mossroad. Remembering another reason I dismissed Power Trac early on, I couldn't picture it being as effective at road maintenance pushing the impliments. As gathered from another thread, at least the 425 sounds inferior to a traditional tractor in using a box blade. Any owners of larger PTs use them for road maintenance?

That I do not know for sure. You could pop into the PT forum and ask a question over there. The PT owners of different size are honest and will tell you what the machines will and will not do well.

Here's what I did when we bought our 20 acres.

I bought a very used late 70's IH2500b tractor loader with cab for $5000. It was a 50PTO hp machine with a built in loader(not detachable) and a 3pt hitch. It was 2wd and had an HST tranny. And a bazillion hours. I used that large machine to cut in a road from the highway with the 3/4yard bucket and a large, heavy box blade. My road is about 500' long and all sand. I obtained a soil map and found a pocket of gravel on my place. So I dug out a trench about a foot deep by 500' long in the sand. I laid down 6" of the gravel and spread it with the box blade. Then I bought many truck loads of slag from the steel mill and used the FEL to distribute it and the box blade to level it. That took many weekends, but I have a road that will last a lifetime.

I also used that machine to remove several large trees. It was nice to drive up to a 10" tree and just push it over, lift up the stump, and push it away.

We also had several thousand trees planted and I used that machine with a 5' brush cutter to keep the weeds down between the rows for 5 years. After that, it wouldn't fit down the rows anymore, as it was too large.

That all sounds peachy so far.

However, once all the large tasks were done, the machine was just too big. It couldn't go through my existing 10 acres of thick woods without damaging everything and it got stuck in the sand very often and I had to constantly use the FEL to push it back out of the soft sand. The R4 loaded tires were darn near worthless in the sand, especially on our very hilly slopes. This is an 8000 pound machine.

So, I started searching for a different sized machine and after several months of looking, test driving, and talking to folks here on TBN and a few farmer friends, I settled on the PT425.

For MY needs (speaking just for me, not anyone else), this machine mows my lawn, clears snow from my driveway, mowed 4 ball diamonds at a little league park weekly for several years, rebuilt two infields, spread countless yards of various materials over large distances like, limestone, granulated limestone, dirt, mulch, sand, black dirt, etc... built and maintained about 2 miles of trails on our property 6' wide. That involved hauling out fallen trees, cut trees, and brush cutting briars and brambles so thick the deer won't go through it.

I can take it into places that conventional tractors of the same size can and will not go. It's much faster at moving material from point A to point B than a conventional tractor. I could go on and on but won't for now.

After the IH2500b sat idle for many years because the little PT425 was doing all the work, I sold the IH for $1500. So I had $3500 in it for about 10-12 years.

What I'm getting at is that you have to decide your tasks and your budget and find a machine that will do them within your guidelines. I needed a large machine to do the initial tasks, and downsize to a property maintenance sized machine for that. I rented a small excavator for a weekend to dig a 24' x 32' garage foundation. That was less than $300. I thought it would take me all weekend. It took me 4 hours. So I dug out a few stumps and I returned the excavator for a 1 day rental and got about $100 back! A backhoe purchase for me would have been foolish.

Looking back on it all, I'd do it similarly. I'd buy a larger, heavier machine to get the initial tasks done, then downsize to a property maintenance sized machine.

Also, knowing what I know now, with my soil types, I could have easily done it all with a larger Power Trac much faster than that IH. The articulated loader design is, well, a superior loader. I can pop a large bucket off in about 3 seconds without getting off the machine. I could pick up the mini-hoe and attach the hydraulics in about 30 seconds to remove any rocks, stumps, etc...., then pop that off, pick up the bucket again, haul it off and come back with fill for the hole. I could swap out for a grapple in 30 seconds and haul off branches, or I could just purchase a grapple bucket. Start running into thick brush? Pop on the brush cutter in 30 seconds and clear the brush.....

Boxblade work? Hmmm.... :laughing: That was your original question, yes? :laughing:

I haven't found a need for a box blade since that initial driveway install. The road has held up that well. And I just used my buckets to grade the infields on the ball diamond rehabs. So, again, I'd suggest you ask the larger PT owners in the Power Trac forum for advice on that subject. Most of them have or had conventional tractors and can give you a good comparison and what they've run into over the years.

Good luck with your decision making. TAKE YOUR TIME! :thumbsup:
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #69  
If your place is steep you're probably going to want front wheel braking. On a traditional tractor that usually means putting it in 4wd.
 
   / 40 Acres, Steep!, 1 Mile Road; Need Advice #70  
Pugemasta,

Since you are looking at other options, check out a Toolcat. It is very popular with commercial snow removal operators:

Toolcat.jpg



Low center of gravity, here is our 5610 on a 27 degree side hill, the hanging chain shows true vertical:

P9250008.JPG



Digging and hauling dirt with a 6', 1 cubic yard bucket:

P5210002.JPG


P5210006.JPG



The 8' box blade:

P3180001.JPG


P3180008.JPG



The 6' box blade on the front:

P2100035.JPG


P7020023.JPG



The 8' brush hog:

PC190004.JPG


PA270003.JPG



The Toolcat forum: https://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/toolcat/

.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

New Wolverine Skid Steer Forks Attachment (A53002)
New Wolverine Skid...
JOHN DEERE 1725 CCS (A53084)
JOHN DEERE 1725...
JOHN DEERE TX LOT NUMBER 152 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE TX LOT...
Rock wood travel trailer (A51694)
Rock wood travel...
2015 DODGE RAM 1500 CREW CAB TRUCK (A51406)
2015 DODGE RAM...
JOHN DEERE 1700 LOT NUMBER 17 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE 1700...
 
Top