Compact tractor Fatality

[majorwager]

Screenshot below contains current details available

 

[mcfarmall]

That's too bad for the guy. I wonder if he drilled a bootleg hole in his ROPS?

 

[Jstpssng]

^^^^All things considered, that's a rather callous comment.

 

[Thomas]

Indeed a shame...RIP.

 

[radios1]

RIP, sad news. no details on why the ROPS failed, it seems inconceivable the ROPS didn't save him..

 

[Jstpssng]

^^^^^ It may not have failed per se, just not been enough to protect him. The tractor may have rolled against a rock or tree, or he could have been thrown free if he wasn't wearing his seatbelt. It doesn't really matter, the results are the same. RIP Mr Moran.

 

[Oldoak]

^^^^^ It may not have failed per se, just not been enough to protect him. The tractor may have rolled against a rock or tree, or he could have been thrown free if he wasn't wearing his seatbelt. It doesn't really matter, the results are the same. RIP Mr Moran.

Agree. No sense at all with armchair analysis, particularly when not knowing any of the details and jumping to conclusions. :confused3:

 

[Deerherd]

August 06, 2018 11:55 AM

A 66-year-old man was killed in a tractor rollover accident in the Town of Avon.

Deputies responded to Linden Street around 9:45 a.m. Saturday for the report of a man pinned under a tractor. Deputies say Charles T. "Tom" Moran was unresponsive when first responders arrived and
Moran was pronounced dead at the scene.

Deputies say Moran was operating a tractor with a front bucket in an attempt to recover a lawn mower that had broken down in the back of the property. He was driving the compact tractor on a wet path that had a downward decline, leading down to the rear lot.

Those factors, according to investigators, caused the tractor to go into a slide and eventually roll over, pinning Moran underneath.

 

[Henro]

Seems like we do not know if the tractor had a ROPS. Maybe it did not.

We also do not know if he was using his seat belt if it did have a ROPS.

MESSAGE to us should be to use what safety gear our tractors have, at all times.

Be interesting to know more details...

Bill

 

[Industrial Toys]

A few years back I stopped to help an elderly couple who had gotten into some kind of trouble with equipment in difficult terrain. I could see their setup for recovery was sketchy and stopped to help.

Just because someone has Rural property doesn't make them a good candidate for operating equipment.

 

[radios1]

Seems like we do not know if the tractor had a ROPS. Maybe it did not.

We also do not know if he was using his seat belt if it did have a ROPS.

MESSAGE to us should be to use what safety gear our tractors have, at all times.

Be interesting to know more details...

Bill

I brought up that subject, and no-one cares how it happened, even though it could save lives:shocked: it's probably better to leave it mysterious here!..

 

[rekees4300]

We also do not know if he was using his seat belt if it did have a ROPS.

MESSAGE to us should be to use what safety gear our tractors have, at all times.

ROPS in use = wear seat belt
ROPS not in use = do not wear seat belt

 

[ruffdog]

If your on a slick hill, put it in 4x4 and lock the diff. Some tires are slick on wet grass and they have zero traction sliding sideways. There should be more awareness and videos to educate tractor owners on these issues.

 

[Milo]

My friend actually survived a similar situation after doing what most would say everything wrong. He was driving his new BX in 2wd down a *steep* concrete drive with the bucket full of dirt, no ballast box, rops up, and no seatbelt. Naturally the rear of the tractor was light, began skidding, accelerated, raised up on the pivoting front axle, tipped over and slid down to the bottom. He said it happened in an instant and jumped away just before it rolled. The roll bar was completely bent over to below seat height.

 

[radios1]

My friend actually survived a similar situation after doing what most would say everything wrong. He was driving his new BX in 2wd down a *steep* concrete drive with the bucket full of dirt, no ballast box, rops up, and no seatbelt. Naturally the rear of the tractor was light, began skidding, accelerated, raised up on the pivoting front axle, tipped over and slid down to the bottom. He said it happened in an instant and jumped away just before it rolled. The roll bar was completely bent over to below seat height.

that's insane, a rops should NEVER be compromised!. there's no sense in having one if it can't protect you!. something similar is used in race cars going over 200 MPH, and they don't fail..

 

[4570Man]

My friend actually survived a similar situation after doing what most would say everything wrong. He was driving his new BX in 2wd down a *steep* concrete drive with the bucket full of dirt, no ballast box, rops up, and no seatbelt. Naturally the rear of the tractor was light, began skidding, accelerated, raised up on the pivoting front axle, tipped over and slid down to the bottom. He said it happened in an instant and jumped away just before it rolled. The roll bar was completely bent over to below seat height.

It was folded or bent in the crash?

 

[Industrial Toys]

News reports are notoriously inaccurate. It's not an accident investigation. People come to all kinds of conclusions!

A ROPS must have some kind of certification to represent some standard of safety. Otherwise, I'm sure off shore manufacturers would build them to look solid but out of soup can material.

I would have no problem welding onto a rops, and drilling enough holes into it to make it look like swiss cheese, I am sure it would still perform it's function, just no longer be certified.

We are not talking about a D10 for crying out loud! Some people just don't get stuff like that, clearly!

 

[majorwager]

Deerherd.
Since there is interest in the circumstances, I am submitting a FOIL request to the Undersheriff to obtain the report. I spoke to the Fire Chief but he was unable to comment.

If the details cause others to THINK before acting, something positive may arise from a tragedy. Will post the results. I am the OP.

 

[ruffdog]

that's insane, a rops should NEVER be compromised!. there's no sense in having one if it can't protect you!. something similar is used in race cars going over 200 MPH, and they don't fail..

ROPs is only Roll Over Protection, not a substantial higher speed crash cage.

 

[CincyFlyer]

ROPs is only Roll Over Protection, not a substantial higher speed crash cage.

Not only that, but most are rated for the mass of the base tractor. Mine is. Then you add 1,800 lbs of FEL and BH, and technically it's undersized.