I would say that 13 years ago these were probably quite different. Efficiency has improved a great deal since then. The resistance strips or elements are only used as a backup when the system cannot keep up. The only bad thing about air source heat pumps vs the ground water loop geothermal pumps is that they have to operate against the outside elements, so in the summer you are trying to expel heat in already hot conditions, and in the winter you are trying to suck heat out of already cold air. With the ground geothermal version, you have continuous 55 degree earth to extract or submit heat to or from. Makes a big difference. You can also heat your hot water with the geothermals. You'll get a sticker shock though when you install them, definitely a long term commitment. The air source models are just a big brother to an air conditioner with benefits in my opinion. Being down in Texas if you dont get extreme cold very often I would think air source would do quite well. In the northern climates where I am at, you need auxillary heat with the air source below 32 degrees or something like that, as there is not enough heat to extract from the outside temps. (gas, electic, wood, etc, controlled by relay switch and outdoor sensor)
Eddie, this is probably more info than you wanted on this right? /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif I guess it boils down to how you will be using the building over the years to justify the cost.