Diesel exhaust fluid

   / Diesel exhaust fluid #41  
Taking away a option even as small as a heated WWF unit sets a president.
Chris

Shure there is an underlining issue of not fixing the problem and just removing the "feature"

my issue is, if they cant seem to fix a heater for something simple like WWF... what are the odds they can successfully design multipul heaters to keep the DEF from freezing and f'n everything up.
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #42  
Personally I've never seen the need for heated washer fluid, and probably I'm not alone..That's probably why they sent checks to the owners after that option didn't pan out...Never heard of AC or radios being recalled and disconnected. That one wouldn't stand for any manufacturer.

As far as power seats, I set mine when I bought it 9 months ago and haven't touched the controls since...Same goes for the pedal adjustments.

I say this living in a cold winter part of the country, I'd actually like to see someone invent heated wiper blades instead.

Just jousting with you Chris...All in good fun.

I see your side of it also. I am opposite. 3 different people drove one of my trucks last weekend alone so all my adjustments get used quite often.

What I am saying is legally GM got away with murder on this WWF heater recall. It set up the whole industry, not just GM, to take the cheap route. I guess I am too RED NECK but there is no way I would stand for a fix like that or lack of. I would have caused such a stink they would have wanted to buy the truck back. Its not so much about losing a little option, its what they could do down the road.

I know this is extreme but what if they had a problem with a cool option on your new truck, something like the brake controller. Instead of fixing it they decide to just deactivate it and give you $100 to get a P3? Now you have the factory one in the dash that does not work and a P3 under doing the work. Part of the reason I bought my Superduties was Ford was the only one with a built in brake controller back in 05. I would flip out if they did not support it along with the rest of the truck.

I just feel us as Americans as a whole have gotten soft. We do not stand up for whats right. I buy something I want it to work. If not the manufacture needs to figure out how to make it work as advertized. By letting them slip by the cheap way and getting off easy sets up the rest of the industry for the same practices.:mad:

Chris
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #43  
I see your side of it also. I am opposite. 3 different people drove one of my trucks last weekend alone so all my adjustments get used quite often.

What I am saying is legally GM got away with murder on this WWF heater recall. It set up the whole industry, not just GM, to take the cheap route. I guess I am too RED NECK but there is no way I would stand for a fix like that or lack of. I would have caused such a stink they would have wanted to buy the truck back. Its not so much about losing a little option, its what they could do down the road.

I know this is extreme but what if they had a problem with a cool option on your new truck, something like the brake controller. Instead of fixing it they decide to just deactivate it and give you $100 to get a P3? Now you have the factory one in the dash that does not work and a P3 under doing the work. Part of the reason I bought my Superduties was Ford was the only one with a built in brake controller back in 05. I would flip out if they did not support it along with the rest of the truck.

I just feel us as Americans as a whole have gotten soft. We do not stand up for whats right. I buy something I want it to work. If not the manufacture needs to figure out how to make it work as advertized. By letting them slip by the cheap way and getting off easy sets up the rest of the industry for the same practices.:mad:

Chris

Chris, while I enjoy your writings, your anti GM stance does get old. I will give you an example of your what your beloved Ford pulled on my father. Now granted this was back in 1978, but I just want to show you what Ford DID with something FAR more serious than a WWH.

My father bought a brand new Ford station wagon in 1978. With about 2500 miles on it, he left it idling in park, got out and walked over to put some items in his truck. Next thing you know the car goes into reverse and smashes into his truck. He calls Ford and lo and behold there is in fact a problem. Want to know how your beloved Ford handled it? They sent him this awful gawdy sticker to put on the dash that read: "Do not leave car idle in park. Use neutral and apply the emergency brake." That was their answer, never did fix the tranny. He sold it that way. At least they did pony up for the damages done, BUT they NEVER fixed the problem.
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #44  
Chris, while I enjoy your writings, your anti GM stance does get old. I will give you an example of your what your beloved Ford pulled on my father. Now granted this was back in 1978, but I just want to show you what Ford DID with something FAR more serious than a WWH.

My father bought a brand new Ford station wagon in 1978. With about 2500 miles on it, he left it idling in park, got out and walked over to put some items in his truck. Next thing you know the car goes into reverse and smashes into his truck. He calls Ford and lo and behold there is in fact a problem. Want to know how your beloved Ford handled it? They sent him this awful gawdy sticker to put on the dash that read: "Do not leave car idle in park. Use neutral and apply the emergency brake." That was their answer, never did fix the tranny. He sold it that way. At least they did pony up for the damages done, BUT they NEVER fixed the problem.


You know little about me so dont make assumptions. I have owned more GM products than I have any other brand including Ford. While I do think there is no comparison to Ford when it comes to trucks that is where my loyalty stops.

If I had that situation and it was not resolved as in your fathers case I would have taken my sticker with me to the dealers and ran it though the front of the building. Don't believe me, you have not met me. I would have then gotten out of the car with the sticker in my hand and said I was coming in to have the service dept help me install it when the car did it again.;) Prove me wrong.

Call me Red Neck or whatever you want but I don't take any crap from anyone and always get even. I would call that even.:D

I have a feeling that what happened with the Toyotas was as much my way of dealing with a issue as it was a problem with the cars themselves.

By the way, I will not own another GM for one reason only, the bailout. Nothing to do with quality, ect. I am done with them.


Chris
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #45  
What I am saying is legally GM got away with murder on this WWF heater recall. It set up the whole industry, not just GM, to take the cheap route. I guess I am too RED NECK but there is no way I would stand for a fix like that or lack of. I would have caused such a stink they would have wanted to buy the truck back. Its not so much about losing a little option, its what they could do down the road.

I know this is extreme but what if they had a problem with a cool option on your new truck, something like the brake controller. Instead of fixing it they decide to just deactivate it and give you $100 to get a P3? Now you have the factory one in the dash that does not work and a P3 under doing the work. Part of the reason I bought my Superduties was Ford was the only one with a built in brake controller back in 05. I would flip out if they did not support it along with the rest of the truck.

I just feel us as Americans as a whole have gotten soft. We do not stand up for whats right. I buy something I want it to work. If not the manufacture needs to figure out how to make it work as advertized. By letting them slip by the cheap way and getting off easy sets up the rest of the industry for the same practices.:mad:

Chris

I'm sure an accountant somewhere said it would be cheaper to give everyone $100 bucks than fix this. That should worry people. What if it was cruise control and they figured it would be cheaper to give people $250 than fix it but it was an option that you used on a regular basis? What if you use the heated WWF to deice your windshield in the middle of winter. The trick of wrapping a hose around a radiator pipe is worthless if your engine is cold.
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #46  
You know little about me so dont make assumptions. I have owned more GM products than I have any other brand including Ford. While I do think there is no comparison to Ford when it comes to trucks that is where my loyalty stops.

If I had that situation and it was not resolved as in your fathers case I would have taken my sticker with me to the dealers and ran it though the front of the building. Don't believe me, you have not met me. I would have then gotten out of the car with the sticker in my hand and said I was coming in to have the service dept help me install it when the car did it again.;) Prove me wrong.

Call me Red Neck or whatever you want but I don't take any crap from anyone and always get even. I would call that even.:D

I have a feeling that what happened with the Toyotas was as much my way of dealing with a issue as it was a problem with the cars themselves.

By the way, I will not own another GM for one reason only, the bailout. Nothing to do with quality, ect. I am done with them.


Chris

Chris - I am not assuming anything. Your anti GM posts here are well documented, and your love of Ford is also well documented. I am not meaning in any manor to start something, that is just the way it is.

It is very easy to say you would drive your vehicle through the showroom, but something tells me you are smarter than that. Because you know in the long run you would pay dearly for it, probably land in jail over it, and in the end it would accomplish nothing.

I hear you on the redneck thing, but again you seem like a sharp guy and I am sure you know there are times when the good guy just does not win.

Regards

Storm
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #47  
pure urea (the majority of the exhaust fluid) has a melting point of ~273 F

which means the systems employ a series of heaters to keep the fluid liquid (especially in cold times and in cold climates) (not just a tank heater but a line heater and injector heater)

The majority of it is Deionized water. 67.5%. The other 32.5% is pure industrial grade Urea, not fertilizer grade.

It freezes at 12*.

We have a fair number of Class 8 diesels with DEF in the fleet right now and for kicks and grins we tried 28%, the same stuff we put on Corn. It works just fine.

You must have one of the earlier trucks that a certain MFG didnt program the sensors properly and you could even run water in them. But maybe you dont I dont know.

Now you cant do that(maybe you can), the sensors will detect if it is not pure DEF.

DEF has a shelf life of 4 months-2 years. The deciding factor is heat. Over 86* and it will start to degrade. So make sure you only buy what you need and store it out of sunlight and in a cool place if possible.

Interesting. I Learn something new everyday. Things just tend to get more complicated. I wonder if they're do the same for tractors...

Yes they are, currently have one on the farm with it. All but Deere and Challengers larger tractors with CAT engines, have SCR.

my issue is, if they cant seem to fix a heater for something simple like WWF... what are the odds they can successfully design multipul heaters to keep the DEF from freezing and f'n everything up.

Um have you read the news? GM cant keep the DEF from freezing, they're having glitches left and right. hopefully they got it fixed this time though (update #20). Im a diehard Duramax Fan, but not afraid to admit their issues.



Now on the topic of DEF. The system is called SCR, Selective Catalytic Reduction.

Simply put it is injected into the exhaust at a variable rate to control NOX emissions. When injection it reacts in the catalyst to convert the NOX into water, Nitrogen and a trace amount of CO2.

NOX and particulates are the two to remember when it comes to diesel emissions.

There are currently 2 systems in place for reducing NOX.

EGR/NOX absorbing catalyst. and SCR. Both systems use Particulate filters for the particles but its important to look at how each system affects that pesky gremlin called the DPF.

The EGR based systems rely on creating colder combustion temperatures and recirculating large amounts of EGR. This creates a cooler combustion which results in less NOX. However anybody who payed attention in school knows that cooler combustion is more inefficient. Which holds true, with the cool combustion the particulates do not get burned which causes the DPF to plug up much faster than on an SCR motor. Also due to the cooler more incomplete combustion fuel efficiency suffers. In addition the added particulates in the system cause premature wear and require more frequent oil changes (Example is the 200hr OCI on the John Deere(EGR) versus the 600hr interval on the case IH (SCR)or 400hr interval on the Massey/Challenger(SCR))

The SCR approach relies on aftertreatment of the NOX. meaning they can tune the engine for maximum power, performance and efficiency and let the SCR system scrub up the large amounts of NOX later on. This also results in less particulates which means fewer regens, longer engine life and longer OCIs.

SCR also allows MFGs to use smaller engines to produce the power needed, again this goes back to the heat factor. Case IH is running a 12.9L In their biggest tractor (they used to run 15L) and are making 600ratedhp (SCR) and 670 peak hp. Challenger is using an 18L engine to make 585hp (EGR)

So is SCR new and not proven? NO!! Its been used at power plants and in Europe for a while.

SCR does have its downfalls though. The main one is the DEF itself. Its a pain to handle. Its mildly corrosive, makes a mess, freezes and doesnt last long. There are more solid solutions in the works though to replace it.
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #48  
I'm sure an accountant somewhere said it would be cheaper to give everyone $100 bucks than fix this. That should worry people. What if it was cruise control and they figured it would be cheaper to give people $250 than fix it but it was an option that you used on a regular basis?

Finally, someone else with there eyes open.:thumbsup:

Chris
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #49  
Chris - I am not assuming anything. Your anti GM posts here are well documented, and your love of Ford is also well documented. I am not meaning in any manor to start something, that is just the way it is.

It is very easy to say you would drive your vehicle through the showroom, but something tells me you are smarter than that. Because you know in the long run you would pay dearly for it, probably land in jail over it, and in the end it would accomplish nothing.

I hear you on the redneck thing, but again you seem like a sharp guy and I am sure you know there are times when the good guy just does not win.

Regards

Storm

Well, if it ever happens maybe you will read about me in the paper.

Chris
 
   / Diesel exhaust fluid #50  
Finally, someone else with there eyes open.:thumbsup:

Chris

I think the heated water bottle is being taken to an absurd conclusion here. I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the heated washer fluid wasn't a destination option, just something that was there like many useless options on the truck I currently have.

If it was special ordered, I'd certainly make a stink about it. Cruise control et.al are must have's in many peoples' book...Those wouldn't get the same treatment. In fact, the only time I've ever heard of this washer thing is on TBN...No other public uproar anywhere..This kind of thing usually gets some press.

There's also the possibility that there was no solution due to a sole supplier...I really don't know. Again, I have never even wondered about having that option and I live in the snow belt. Heated wipers would be much more effective.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

New/Unused Quick Attach Post Driver (A51573)
New/Unused Quick...
2019 Krause 8005-30 Excelerator - High Speed Vertical Tillage - 30 FT Working Width (A53472)
2019 Krause...
2005 International 7400 Chassis Truck, VIN # 1HTWGAAT75J048748 (A51572)
2005 International...
NEW 78'' Wolverine Skid Steer Land Leveler (A53002)
NEW 78'' Wolverine...
2018 Lexus IS300 Sedan (A51694)
2018 Lexus IS300...
2009 Kubota KX080-3 Mini Excavator (A51573)
2009 Kubota...
 
Top