Comparison Mahindra or Massey

[Salvo57]

This is my first tractor, will be doing mostly digging, I have the option to buy a 2015 Mahindra 3616 with loader Hydrostatic trans, 56 hr. or 2015 Massey 1739E with loader Hydro tran, 120 hrs the cost is the same $17K , i will be putting a backhoe attachment on . I have researched and to me it looks like both are equal , would like input on pros and cons , need help too split my indecision ,need owner input !!!
Thx

 

[mapper]

Check out the number of posts on problems with both makes of tractors, then make your decision. I personally think Massey has a lot better quality control on their products. I have had no issues with my 1734e.

 

[MAN IN BLACK]

Personnally, I am a MF man...ran JD as a kid, it's all my Dad ever owned.
Mahindra is non existing in this part of the province.
I have a MF dealer 15 minutes from here and they have excellent service.
I never had a major problem through the 15 years I made business with them !

 

[Sysop]

Neither company "makes" either of those models. All of the "fit and finish" and "quality control" has nothing to do with Massey or Mahindra. Mahindra does use their mCRD engine on their Mitsubishi built 3616. Interesting note on the Mahindra mCRD engine, it was developed in partnership with Perkins, the company whose diesel engines made Massey Ferguson famous.

With these two tractors, your decision should come down to your local dealer support. Which has the better/more established dealer in your area? Which has the better parts and service departments? How far do you need to travel with the tractor to get dealer service?

 

[otlski]

I have no experiance with either brand. Can I assume that you are looking at Goff's? I see that they have just started to carry Mahindra, will they continue to carry the Massy's or are they considered leftovers as they phase them out?

 

[Groo]

go by dealer support

 

[Salvo57]

Yes it seems Geoff is leaning towards Mahindra, as I was pricing new salesman never mentioned the Masseys on the lot, I'm buying from private seller . They both seem of equal value , my closest dealer would be Mahindra

 

[cford36]

Have you operated both tractors? I personally did not like the layout and feel of Mahindra. If you haven't I highly suggest you do, that may push you one way or the other.

 

[Sysop]

The feel of a machine is easier to adjust to than availability of parts and service, to which there is no adjusting. Testing each machine out is a valid point, but I'd still stick with a brand I can get local parts and support for over a layout variance that I can adjust myself to.

 

[cford36]

The feel of a machine is easier to adjust to than availability of parts and service, to which there is no adjusting. Testing each machine out is a valid point, but I'd still stick with a brand I can get local parts and support for over a layout variance that I can adjust myself to.

I looked it up and he has 3 Massey and 3 Mahindra dealers within 50 miles. And yes the closest one of both is the same dealer.

I also don't mean to disregard what the dealer is like. I chose not to go with another John Deere partially because they had questionable service practices and a sales office that couldn't be bothered to get out of their chair. So it is a consideration. But you also wouldn't buy a car without driving it. (at least most wouldn't)

 

[Salvo57]

Yes u guys r right I should drive each and make by decision

 

[oldpilgrim]

I'm pretty sure Sysop is incorrect on the mcrd engine​. The 3616 is an interim tier 4 as is it's lower powered brother the 3016 which I have. It has a Mitsubishi engine and the whole tractor is Mitsubishi built. If you want a trouble free non final tier 4 machine, then the 3616 is the one to get. They are in big demand and I'm surprised you found one. It is an excellent machine.

 

[Sysop]

I thought by 2015 the T4 implementation was done. oldpilgrim is correct, if it is pre-tier4 then it is a Mitsu engine. If it is tier4 then it is the mCRD engine. Either are really good engines.

 

[2ndhalf]

The feel of a machine is easier to adjust to than availability of parts and service, to which there is no adjusting. Testing each machine out is a valid point, but I'd still stick with a brand I can get local parts and support for over a layout variance that I can adjust myself to.

True only if you are an average sized person. Because of my size (6'4' 300+) I make most of my buying decisions based on if I fit in it (Cars, Mowers, tractors). My little Massey is unusually roomy for a little tractor.

I think he won't go wrong with either.. if it were me I would buy based on the tractor I could get the most information about... was it a lemon who traded it etc.

 

[2ndhalf]

I thought by 2015 the T4 implementation was done. oldpilgrim is correct, if it is pre-tier4 then it is a Mitsu engine. If it is tier4 then it is the mCRD engine. Either are really good engines.

Agree, I wouldn't be afraid of either engine...

Tractordata.com shows that MF has a
Shibaura N843T-F
turbocharged diesel
3-cylinder
liquid-cooled
91.3 ci [1.5 L]

Shibaura is also a very good engine.. Ford has put them in their compact tractors for years.

 

[Salvo57]

The dealer for both tractors is 17 miles from my house

 

[Salvo57]

ok decision made missed out on Massey , drove to look at Mahindra 2hrs away, was all set to pull the trigger but found 2010 Mahindra 3535 , with M120 loader and a 485 backhoe with hydraulic thumb,300 hrs. Picked up today so far dug up 13 hedges and 2 stumps, this has shuttle shift and very happy as i started clearing land with briers and small brush put in 4x4 and just let her go lol ,im luving machine so far!! Thx for all the input . cost $19,700 Im very happy it has the thumb works great.

 

[ronchp]

Good deal. The 3535 is about 1500 pounds more tractor than the other 2 you were looking at. Sounds like a nice setup.

 

[TomSeller]

ok decision made missed out on Massey , drove to look at Mahindra 2hrs away, was all set to pull the trigger but found 2010 Mahindra 3535 , with M120 loader and a 485 backhoe with hydraulic thumb,300 hrs. Picked up today so far dug up 13 hedges and 2 stumps, this has shuttle shift and very happy as i started clearing land with briers and small brush put in 4x4 and just let her go lol ,im luving machine so far!! Thx for all the input . cost $19,700 Im very happy it has the thumb works great.

Sounds nice. Pictures?