Are all sub compacts essentially equal?

[Cherokee140]

I had the chance to see a J2020 some months ago and posted some photos. Can't remember the thread title right now. The LS may be nearly identical in dimension but when sitting on it, it feels much bigger than a JD 1025R.

I think it was the Boomer 30 that I sat on and I can tell you that is a much larger machine. It just did not seem as nice as the Kubota or the JD...or even Mahendra....I can't put my finger on what it was but it just seemed cheaper somehow.

 

[chvfrk98]

I am not sure that is the word I would use. And right or wrong that is one reason I liked Kubota...I know who made the thing. Yea I know brands get relabeled all the time, I just don't like it.

They are all the same aren't they. Especially those D's!

I was very close between Kubota and the Mahindra I finally chose. Weight and the beefer frame was a big choice for me. Like what was said earlier, a little extra safety/stability.

 

[GManBart]

I think it was the Boomer 30 that I sat on and I can tell you that is a much larger machine. It just did not seem as nice as the Kubota or the JD...or even Mahendra....I can't put my finger on what it was but it just seemed cheaper somehow.

The Boomer 30/LS G3033 is definitely larger, and quite a bit heavier. I don't recall how NH markets them, but LS says the G series is their "basic" tractor, so it's reasonable to expect it won't be as polished/refined as what you'd find from other brands/models of similar size.

 

[TSO]

I want to say that the Boomer 30 is NOT an LS G series. The G series are the small NH WorkMaster tractors. I think the Boomer 30 is unique to NH, in that it's a Bonner 35 (LS R3039) with less HP. LS has slightly more models available now

 

[GManBart]

I want to say that the Boomer 30 is NOT an LS G series. The G series are the small NH WorkMaster tractors. I think the Boomer 30 is unique to NH, in that it's a Bonner 35 (LS R3039) with less HP. LS has slightly more models available now

The LS G series and R3039 appear to use the same size frame (66" wheelbase) and weigh about the same (within a hundred pounds or so if memory serves me). The Boomer 30 seems to have some features of both...with a different (CNH) engine. :confused2: The WorkMaster 35 does appear to be the same as the LS G3033.

Either way, the Boomer 30 is a much bigger platform than the smaller Boomers that are J series LS models.

 

[Poopdeck Pappy]

OK So the 99% use piece would be mowing the lawn, maintaining a 275' gravel driveway and moving "stuff" around with the FEL for DW who loves to garden but needs help with the heavy stuff. The extreme projects would be clearing downed pine trees (with the help of a chainsaw) digging drain lines and clearing brush from our 2.5 acre hill.
Best
Chris

Sounds to me like a Kubota BX25D would be a good fit. The backhoe will come in handy for digging drain lines and digging out pine stumps.

Or, if you're really flush with cash, the Kubota B26 is the next step up in size, capability and price.

Ok, now everyone else can resume the urination olympics about tractor specs.

 

[cmkh3]

I test drove a BX25D the other day. It did drive nice on the blacktop but I am not buying it to keep it clean, I have a car for that job.
Best
Chris

 

[94BULLITT]

I think you should look at small compacts like the Kubota B series and JD 2000 series. They are not a whole lot more money but they are a good bit more machine. A subcompact is a little on the small side for a primary tractor that is going to be used in brush/ woods.

 

[Cherokee140]

They are not much more money, and the 3 is not much more again. But check on that backhoe attachment....one of them I know you have to crawl under the machine and take off bolts...at least that is what the dealer said. The real price difference comes in with the backhoe's....some are more then $5k more expensive then the one right below it....pretty crazy.

I think we have come to the agreement that New Holland does not have something marketed in the sub compact area. That will leave you with the others we have talked about.

And Going back to what we talked about before I really think they are all very close to the same with just a few little differences between them. I did not look at LS as there is no dealer here and (I freely admit) I wanted a big name. Yes you do pay more for it to say John Deere, Kubota on the side, but there is a bit of mind that goes with it.

 

[radioman]

Well - I said this before, but going to say it again. For me it was the dealer who took the time to talk to me and answered questions and if I got answers that I felt it was BS, I am walking out the door. JD BS'sd me and they were 10 mins away.Never even bothered to say hang on , let me get back to you with right info. This tells me they are honest. Distance has nothing to to with tractor choices, its all about being comfortable in the tractor and buying one from a knowledgeable person.
TO OP- You are buying a tractor to do chores around the place and you want to be able to service it at any given time whether its maintenance or repairs with your dealer.