I believe this is going to boil down to a gear vs HST type answer.. IE.. what works best for the individual is BEST.
if you have an application where you use the cpu 2x per day, 8hrs apart.. with absolutely no need for it inbetween.. then yeah.. power it down.
If yuo on the other hand need to use it frequently all day.. then leaving it on is a time savings.
Also keep in mind that a computers absolute maximum power rating is not what it always draws.. sleep and hibernate modes can significantly cut power.. especially with new power savings monitors that actually soft-off the spendy crt.. or even the more efficient lcd units.. etc.
soundguy