Post Hole Digger Comparision

   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #1  

saxon11

Bronze Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2021
Messages
60
Location
Minnesota
Tractor
TYM T474
I'm looking to add a PHD to my attachments for my 47HP TYM. I'm looking for 12" capacity. Here are the options.

1. from Dealer for $1,250
2. from TSC, for $650. That is half the price!

I'm looking to use it for planting a few hundred trees each year. Is the dealer on worth twice the price?
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #2  
Those are extremely simple devices. I personally wouldnt even consider a $1200 version. I would worry more on the type/quality of the auger bits than to be worried about the implement itself. My .02

But, i guess one reason i don’t worry about my phd is because i run it on a small tractor at a low throttle so if i hit something the tractor stalls before the phd is stressed at all, and that’s preferable to me. I can crank it up after i look at whats down there. I’d rather take longer than find the weakest link.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #4  
I have the TSC one, County Line brand. It spins a 9 inch auger. I have drilled so far about 20 3 foot deep holes with it. Stalled my 23 HP tractor once. It works great. I can't see spending twice as much unless it was needed for drilling thousands of holes. Here on Whidbey Island the ground is all glacial till so rocks can be quite common. Every time I drill a hole the auger hits and pulls up several rocks. That would seem to be tough duty.
Eric
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #5  
What are the differences between the two units? Does one have slip clutch, hex drive for auger while other no slip clutch with round drive for auger. Does one have longer boom so lifts higher so can drill deeper hole?

To me the features should be considered along with price.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #6  
I'm looking to add a PHD to my attachments for my 47HP TYM. I'm looking for 12" capacity. Here are the options.

1. from Dealer for $1,250
2. from TSC, for $650. That is half the price!

I'm looking to use it for planting a few hundred trees each year. Is the dealer on worth twice the price?


Before you open your wallet I want to make your life easier;
DO NOT use the standard auger unless you have sandy soil.

Invest in a tree transplanting auger to do this as the tapered
transplanting auger will eliminate the stress that the compacted
soil will create against the auger as it penetrates the soil.

I convinced my brother to do this with his post hole digger and
he had no problems getting to depth for his deep post holes
using his small agco tractor.

When I planted my first annual Christmas tree, I had a deep hole
that I filled with shovels full of pea gravel for drainage and
concrete sand until the root ball was near the surface and then
I covered it with concrete sand.

Forty years later that first live potted Christmas tree is 50 feet tall.

The only faster way to do this is rent a backhoe with a very wide
bucket to plant the trees.

The downside to this method is that the block of dirt will have to be
broken up and the rocks in the dirt will be hidden where with a
transplanting auger the rocks will be spit out where you can see them
and toss them into a wheel barrow or the loader bucket if you have one
mounted on your tractor.

The transplanting auger will create a wide tapered hole that will let
the tree roots grow rapidly in the loosened soil if watered regularly
with a hose or drip irrigation method.

A tree transplanting auger will save you a great deal of work and
will create less stress on your mules rear PTO and the gearbox of the
post hole digger.

I have talked about the transplanting augers before on the forum and
uploaded links and pictures.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #7  
I picked up a Mahindra branded PHD at auction for $300 about six years ago (about 150 less than TSC county Line at the time) in looking at the two, the only difference I found was the color of the paint. both were round drive/no slip clutch & identical gear boxes. Got augers at TSC & no problems with my set-up.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #8  
Deere seems a bit extreme in their pricing. I wonder who actually makes their Post Hole Diggers? I know they buy other brands and paint them green for different things. I wonder if they are doing the same with their auger?

I have a Leinbach Line post hole digger. The auger was really bad, so I bought a Speeco auger and it was a lot better. Having replacement teeth made a huge difference. Then I couldn't find any Speeco replacement teeth, and I needed to drill a bunch of holes to finish off my fence, I bought the Country Line auger. That has proven to be the best auger ever!!! It drills through the hardest clay, in the middle of August, when it's at it's driest.

My tractor is 37 hp. My biggest problem with the Country Line auger is that it can drill down too fast and burry itself in the ground. It's super aggressive!!!!

If I was buying today, I would get the Country Line!!!
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #9  
What are the differences between the two units? Does one have slip clutch, hex drive for auger while other no slip clutch with round drive for auger. Does one have longer boom so lifts higher so can drill deeper hole?

To me the features should be considered along with price.
Never seen one with a slip clutch, always a shear pin.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #10  
I'm looking to use it for planting a few hundred trees each year.
You may want to consider a SSQA auger. Easier to connect, no neck strain, can reverse if you hit something solid, may be tax deducable if starting tree farm.
20221004_152049.jpg

Using planning auger to remove tree stump
20220610_145231.jpg
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #11  
I'm looking to add a PHD to my attachments for my 47HP TYM. I'm looking for 12" capacity. Here are the options.

1. from Dealer for $1,250
2. from TSC, for $650. That is half the price!

I'm looking to use it for planting a few hundred trees each year. Is the dealer on worth twice the price?
Everything at every dealer is twice the price but not twice as nice. TSC augers are just as good as the dealers. Of course the dealer will love to skim an extra 600 off of you just for the heck of it. Dealer gets the same ones from China or India that the other stores get. I've had two made out of car rear differential gear boxes. They're still going, from the 1950"s.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #12  
I bought the equivalent of a County Line PHD for my first fence installation 25 years ago. It was a great implement and worked well. For trees I would recommend the tree type auger that Leonz recommends.
I redid my fence in 2021 and opted to get an ssqa hydraulic auger. Night and day difference! Easy to position, a lot of auger bit options, reverse direction, and down pressure make it a very easy and quick operation. They do cost significantly more though.

If you're doing a lot of holes on a regular basis an ssqa hydraulic auger may be worth the investment.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #13  
You may want to consider a SSQA auger. Easier to connect, no neck strain, can reverse if you hit something solid, may be tax deducable if starting tree farm.
View attachment 776982
Using planning auger to remove tree stump
View attachment 776983

I have been tempted to try the stump head on my Land Pride SA20. Have you used it on larger stumps with any success? If it would chip away at a 2-3' stump I would be interested.
Tell me about your experiences, and price if you don't mind.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #15  
also put some thought into the depth you want to dig and soil type. Both stressors on a phd.

I am in sandy soil, no rocks/stones/pebbles. Little to no stress using big bore augers to 7' depths.

My TSC phd is plenty sufficient for these light and danger free soil area.

Cheers
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #16  
Danuser are you working with a partner or solo on that many holes? maybe explain application in more detail. Mine is bullet proof, but w/a 9" auger. Interested to hear of the tree planting, assuming pines?
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #17  
I have been tempted to try the stump head on my Land Pride SA20. Have you used it on larger stumps with any success? If it would chip away at a 2-3' stump I would be interested.
Tell me about your experiences, and price if you don't mind.

Pay attention to the cutting sequence drawing. Small tractor with low oil flow, the auger can screw in and take too large of a bite. Reverse auger 1/2 turn, lift FEL to reduce down pressure and auger more. May have to cycle FEL in and out of float for some stumps.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #18  
I built a hydraulic driven auger that mounts to the side of my bucket and will also slip into the 2" hitch receiver on a QA plate. Operates off of the loader hydraulic controls. Just a garage sale motor with a cylindrical adapter to mount the auger. Plenty of down-force if needed. Reversible in case it runs into a boulder. Biggest benefit is setting it to a location that I can eyeball without having to have a hawk's neck. Plus minor angle corrections can be make using the loader controls instead of shifting the transmission back & forth. At my place, the deer break the fence posts year 'round. With this setup, the bucket can push the existing wire fence away enough to drill a replacement hole without tangling it up in the auger.
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #19  
I bought a cheapo PHD, it never worked well in tough soil, so I got rid of it and bought a Bush Hog brand PHD, night and day difference, it's really that much better!

SR
 
   / Post Hole Digger Comparision #20  
I wasn't aware that these stump grinders existed. This seems to be intended for the skid steer market, but will they work on a 3 point hitch type of PHD? There's no reverse on the 3PH PHD so I'm not sure how well they'd work. I can see them working well in one direction but then needing to be extracted manually.
 
 

Marketplace Items

SAMSUNG REFRIGERATOR/FREEZER (A60432)
SAMSUNG...
2023 CATERPILLAR 120 MOTORGRADER (A60429)
2023 CATERPILLAR...
2012 TEX MEX TRAILER LOW BOY GOOSENECK (A58214)
2012 TEX MEX...
UNUSED FUTURE 100YG PIPE GRIPPING MACHINE (A60432)
UNUSED FUTURE...
John Deere 5055E (A53317)
John Deere 5055E...
2020 PETERBILT 567 (A58214)
2020 PETERBILT 567...
 
Top