My actual experience was different. I originally tried 4-link ladders and they were ineffective for my 43x16-20 R4's. Most of the cross chains got lost in the tread. The DUO's solved that but were too rough. Part of the problem is that my tires are actually a skid steer tire and not all that common. The fairly small running diameter and patterns which were 1-chain link too long resulted in large gaps between the patterns. The supplier
www.canadianchains.com actually changed the cross link pattern of my DUOs to a shorter one the year after I bought mine (but I bought mine from a different seller). I fixed that roughness by ordering extra DUO patterns and converting the DUOs to H-pattern and as shown in the thread linked in my post #3 of this thread. But even without that change the DUOs were much more effective than the ladders.
I had a large end-gap (4-side chain link gap) on my now H-pattern (formerly DUO) chains which I filled with a straight cross chain as you suggest. After a while the chains would shift badly at the end gap. I solved that by adding another DUO pattern across the end gap. The photos are in the thread referenced in my post 3 above but I'll post them here:
Chains with straight cross chain at end gap:
View attachment 535263
Replace straight cross chain with DUO pattern (left tire), right tire DUO pattern not yet added:
View attachment 535264 View attachment 535266
That stopped the shifting problem and improved traction/ride over the end gap.
I suspect I would not have had the shifting problem if I could have followed your recommendations and ran the chains loose. However I have less than 2" between the side chain and ROPS support bracket so I needed to keep the rear chains tight. The tensioners likely were the cause of the chains shifting. I had a similar clearance problem with my front chains and could not even mount chains until I got 2" spacers. The front chains are small H-patterns which I run fairly loose (just one bungee in a triangle pattern connecting 3 points on the side chain) because there is now good clearance.
I am finally going to fix the rear chain clearance by adding spacers. I got a quote from Bro-tek before Christmas and intend to order them soon. I'll put the spacers on in the spring because I don't want to mess with them with all the snow. I'm not confident I can handle the loaded rear tires so I will get a tire service company to install the spacers after I take the chains off. So next year winter I won't have to fuss with the rear tire tight clearance and will run them looser.
Had I been able to run my original 4-link ladders looser I may not have had the problem with them sinking in the tread and they would have been fine. If I had installed spacers from the start I may have ended up with 2-link ladders on the rears instead of trying DUOs. The DUOs were very rough but converting them to H-patterns fixed that and I suspect they are somewhat more effective than ladders.
I was fortunate to have a local supplier who stocks bulk chain patterns at about 1/2 the price of the online stores so I could modify my chains at a reasonable cost.